On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Wagrvuy Wine Making Kit9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Mr. BeerView on Amazon - 3
Craft A Brew Recipe KitView on Amazon - 4
American Cream Ale Homebrew Beer Ingredient KitView on Amazon - 5
Craft a BrewView on Amazon - 6
Brewer's Best German Oktoberfest Home Brewing Ingredient KitView on Amazon - 7
BrewDemon Little Demon Craft Beer Bonus KitView on Amazon
A counter full of fruit at harvest time, or a shelf of empty bottles waiting for a batch, is when most home brewers start weighing a beer brewing kit vs wine making kit. The short answer: a beer kit suits a brewer who wants a drinkable batch from grain and hops, while a wine kit suits someone happy to wait out a longer ferment from fruit, and the kits in this guide show how batch size and included gear differ.
Runners-up to consider
Mr. BeerCheck price on Amazon
Craft A Brew Recipe KitCheck price on Amazon
American Cream Ale Homebrew Beer Ingredient KitCheck price on Amazon
Craft a BrewCheck price on Amazon
Brewer's Best German Oktoberfest Home Brewing Ingredient KitCheck price on Amazon
BrewDemon Little Demon Craft Beer Bonus KitCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Beer brewing kit vs wine making kit: the short list
Beer and wine kits share the same shape: a fermenter, ingredients, bottles and patience. The table below lines up what each side asks of the brewer, using only what the listings state.
| Choice | What goes in | Batch in the listings | Ready time the listing states |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beer kit | Grain and hops, brewed and bottled | 1 gallon to 5 gallons | Ready to drink in 3 to 4 weeks, per the Mr. Beer listing |
| Wine kit | Fruit, fermented and bottled | No wine kit listing in this guide | Not stated |
Start with the drink, not the kit. A beer kit brews a batch from malt extract, hops, water and yeast, and the listings here run from a 1 gallon starter to a 5 gallon complete kit. A wine kit ferments fruit into wine, and no wine kit listing sits in this guide, so the wine side below leans on the wine kit guides on this site. Our wine making kits for beginners guide walks through a first wine kit.
The kits in this guide
The gear section below lists the kits in this guide, from the most complete kit to the refill that needs a starter kit beside it. No wine kit listing sits in this guide, so all 4 are beer kits.
| Kit | Stated batch | What the listing includes | Stated weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Northern Brewer Homebrewing Starter Kit, Chinook IPA | 5 gallons | Brew kettle, 6.5 gallon fermentor, hydrometer, bottling bucket, capper and caps | Not stated |
| Mr. Beer Craft Beer Making Kit, Golden Ale | 2 gallons | 2 gallon brew keg, 11 reusable bottles, hopped malt extract, carbonation drops | 6.0 pounds |
| Craft A Brew Oktoberfest Ale Beer Making Kit | 1 gallon | Complete equipment and supplies, guide to craft brewing | 5.2 pounds |
| Craft A Brew Oktoberfest Ale Recipe Kit, Refill | 1 gallon | Hops, dry malt extract, yeast, sanitizer, grain steeping bag | Not stated |
The Northern Brewer kit is the most complete of the set: a 5 gallon stainless brew kettle, a 6.5 gallon fermentor with spigot, lid and bubbler airlock, a bottling bucket, a bottle filler, a 21 inch stainless spoon, 5 ft of clear tubing and a Royal Crown bottle capper with caps (60ct.). The Mr. Beer kit is the compact starter: a 2 gallon keg, 11 reusable 25 oz bottles and hopped malt extract, with a brew time of 30 minutes and a ready time of 3 to 4 weeks. The Craft A Brew starter is the small-batch kit: a 1 gallon Oktoberfest ale kit with complete equipment and supplies, assembled by hand in Orlando. The refill is ingredients only: hops, dry malt extract, yeast, sanitizer and a grain steeping bag for the next 1 gallon batch, and the listing says to grab a recipe refill rather than another starter set.
Batch size decides the gear
Batch size is the first choice in a beer brewing kit vs wine making kit comparison, because it decides the fermenter, the kettle and the bottle count. A 1 gallon kit suits a small batch and a short shelf: the Craft A Brew starter lists 9.0 by 9.0 by 16.0 inches at 5.2 pounds, and the refill lists 8.5 by 5.25 by 5.5 inches. A 2 gallon kit suits a brewer who wants more than a gallon without a big kettle: the Mr. Beer kit lists an 18.5 by 13.75 by 20.0 inch footprint at 6.0 pounds, with 11 reusable bottles. A 5 gallon kit suits a brewer who wants a full batch: the Northern Brewer kit lists 14.0 by 14.0 by 23.0 inches and yields 5 gallons, filling 50 bottles.
Wine kits work the same way, with the batch size deciding the fermenter and the bottle count, but no wine kit listing sits in this guide, so compare the wine side in our hydrometer vs refractometer for wine comparison and our carboy vs fermentation bucket comparison before buying.
What comes in the box
A starter kit should hold everything for a first batch. The Northern Brewer kit lists a brew kettle, a fermentor, a hydrometer, a lab thermometer, a bottling bucket, a bottle filler, a spoon, tubing, cleaner and sanitizer, a bottle brush and a capper with caps. The Mr. Beer kit lists a 2 gallon brew keg, 11 reusable bottles, hopped malt extract and carbonation drops, and says all you need beside it is water and common kitchen items. The Craft A Brew starter lists complete equipment and supplies with a guide to craft brewing. The refill lists ingredients only, with sanitizer, hops, dry malt extract, specialty yeast strains and a grain steeping bag, so it suits a brewer who already owns the starter kit.
What this guide does not cover
This is a kit comparison, not a brewing manual. It does not give recipes, brewing steps or fermenting schedules: the kit instructions give those, and the Mr. Beer listing states only that a batch brews in 30 minutes, ferments in 10 to 14 days and is ready to drink 7 to 14 days later. Follow the instructions in the kit and the guidance from the maker for each batch.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is a beer brewing kit or a wine making kit easier for a beginner?
The Mr. Beer kit is built for a first-time brewer, with step-by-step instructions and a brew time of 30 minutes, and the Northern Brewer kit lists foolproof instructions with a full set of gear. A wine kit asks for the same kind of patience, and a first wine kit is the place to start on that side.
How much beer does a kit make?
It depends on the kit. The Craft A Brew starter and refill list 1 gallon, the Mr. Beer kit lists 2 gallons, and the Northern Brewer kit yields 5 gallons, filling 50 bottles.
Do I need extra equipment beyond the kit?
Not for the starter kits in this guide. The Mr. Beer kit says all you need beside it is water and common kitchen items, and the Northern Brewer kit lists a kettle, fermentor, bottling bucket and capper in the box. The refill is ingredients only, so it needs the starter kit beside it.
Can I reuse a beer kit for the next batch?
Yes, with a refill. The Craft A Brew refill lists hops, dry malt extract, yeast, sanitizer and a grain steeping bag for the next 1 gallon batch, and the Mr. Beer bottles are reusable.
What if I want to make wine instead?
Then start with a wine kit, not a beer kit. No wine kit listing sits in this guide, so compare fermenters in our fermentation kit vs fermentation crock comparison first.
More preserving guides
See every wine making guide and all fermentation kits guides.
More picks: wine making kits for beginners, cider making kits and carboy vs fermentation bucket.





