How We Pick
The Harvest Score
Every product we recommend carries a Harvest Score out of 10. The same five criteria apply to every product in a category, and the weights are fixed and published here rather than adjusted to suit a conclusion.
| Criterion | Weight | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | 35% | The specifications that decide whether the product does its job: jar capacity and gauge type for canners; tray area, wattage and temperature range for dehydrators; stated batch capacity for freeze dryers; seal width and modes for vacuum sealers; jar fit and lid design for fermentation kits; reach for fruit pickers; basket capacity for presses; discs and capacity for food mills. |
| Build | 25% | Aluminum or stainless construction, stainless grade, BPA-free plastics, food-safe wood, gaskets and seals, handles and what is included. |
| Value | 25% | What you get within the guide’s price range, counting what you still have to buy, such as jars, a rack, bags or a separate gauge. |
| Safety | 10% | Stated features and listings: an overpressure plug and a stated gauge on pressure canners, UL or ETL and auto shut-off on electric appliances, food-grade materials where food touches the product. |
| Warranty | 5% | Length and scope of the written warranty, including vessels, gauges, heating elements, motors and pumps. |
Safety counts for powered products and for listings that state safety features. Where it does not apply, the score is taken over the remaining 90 percent. We never skip a criterion because a brand stayed quiet: if a warranty term or safety listing is not published, that criterion scores zero. A buyer cannot compare what is not published.
How products get on the list
We write for first-time canners with a summer garden, gardeners putting up a large harvest every fall, and homesteaders who preserve most of their food. For each guide we start with what is sold in the United States in that category and price range, then work from the product listing, its specifications, the maker’s stated ratings, the manual where it is published, the warranty terms and the contents of the box. A product needs meaningful published specifications and an identifiable seller to be considered. When a listing leaves something out, we say so and note what you would still need to buy before first use.
We run no product trials of our own, and we do not take physical measurements of products. Every capacity, size or wattage comes from the manufacturer or the listing and is labeled that way. We review, evaluate, compare, rate and recommend, and our scores are a structured reading of published information, not a promise about how a unit will behave in your kitchen.
What we leave out
We leave out canning recipes, processing times, pressures and altitude adjustments, even when a listing includes them. Use current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation guidance for those. We leave out any claim that vacuum sealing or fermenting makes food keep safely for a stated length of time, and any suggestion of methods that food safety authorities advise against. Products with no meaningful specifications, or with an unidentifiable seller, do not make the list either. Our Food Safety Disclaimer sets out the basics, and the Editorial Policy covers how articles are produced, including how data is collected and text is drafted, and how both are checked against the listing before publication.
Corrections
Every article shows the date it was last updated, and we revisit a guide when a product in it changes. If you find something wrong, write to [email protected] with the page and the canning detail in question, and we will check it against the source.
