Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Black+Decker 14 Cu Ft vs 17 Cu Ft: Which One Should You Buy?
Cold Storage

Black+Decker 14 Cu Ft vs 17 Cu Ft: Which One Should You Buy?

Black+Decker 14 cu ft vs 17 cu ft, compared on two listings: a 14.6 cu ft top freezer refrigerator and a 17 cu ft convertible freezer refrigerator.

On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 17BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 179.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.6BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.69.7/10View on Amazon

Harvest season fills the kitchen fast, and the question of where it all goes comes down to cold space. The black+decker 14 cu ft vs 17 cu ft choice pits a top freezer refrigerator against a convertible freezer refrigerator from the same brand, and the listings make the trade clear: one keeps fresh and frozen food in a familiar split, while the other changes roles as storage needs change. We compared the two listings side by side, using only what each maker states.

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: pick the 14.6 cu ft BR1460HW if you want a standard top freezer refrigerator for a kitchen, with adjustable temperature control and a removable wire freezer shelf. Pick the 17 cu ft BUC1700XS if you want more room and a unit that converts between freezer and refrigerator, with glass shelves and an LED display. The 17 cu ft example weighs 165.3 pounds against 134.2 pounds for the 14.6 cu ft example, so measure the doorway and the floor space before ordering either one.

Two examples

BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 17

BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 17

BLACK+DECKER9.7/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 17 cu ft convertible freezer refrigerator with glass shelves, an LED display and garage ready placement, rated ENERGY STAR.

Pros

  • Converts between freezer and full size refrigerator as storage needs change
  • Glass shelves and a 17 cu ft capacity for bulk items and family storage
  • Electronic control with an LED display for precise temperature control
  • Garage ready and ENERGY STAR rated, with frost free technology

Cons

  • Weighs 165.3 pounds, heavier than the 134.2 pound BR1460HW example
  • Measures 31.9 inches wide, so it needs more floor space than the 14.6 cu ft example
  • No top freezer layout for shoppers who want a separate frozen section above the fresh food
  • No removable wire freezer shelf is stated
BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.6

BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.6

BLACK+DECKER9.7/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 14.6 cu ft top freezer refrigerator with adjustable temperature control, frost-free auto-defrost and a removable wire freezer shelf.

Pros

  • Top freezer layout keeps frozen food above the fresh food section
  • Adjustable temperature control for the refrigerator and the top freezer sections
  • Frost-free auto-defrost keeps the interior free from ice build-up
  • Energy Star certified with a removable wire freezer shelf for larger items

Cons

  • 14.6 cu ft of capacity holds less than the 17 cu ft BUC1700XS example
  • No convertible freezer mode is stated
  • No glass shelves are stated
  • No garage ready claim is stated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Runners-up to consider

Black+Decker 14 Cu Ft vs 17 Cu Ft: side by side

Refrigerator Harvest Score Type Capacity Dimensions Weight Warranty
BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 17 9.7/10 Convertible freezer refrigerator 17 Cu. Ft. 31.9 x 28.0 x 68.1 inches 165.3 pounds 1 Year Manufacturer
BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.6 9.7/10 Top freezer refrigerator 14.6 Cu. Ft. 26.3 x 27.9 x 66.0 inches 134.2 pounds 1 Year Manufacturer

Numbers in this comparison come from the maker as the listing shows them, checked 14 November 2026.

What each size is for

The BR1460HW is a full size refrigerator with a top freezer, described for kitchens in homes and apartments. It suits a household that wants fresh food below and frozen food above, with a deep freezer shelf for frozen meals, packaged meats, leftovers and ice cream.

The BUC1700XS is a convertible freezer refrigerator that changes into a full size refrigerator, so it suits a household that needs extra storage for meat and bulk items and wants the unit to change roles. The maker calls it garage ready, which makes it a fit for a garage or a second storage spot as well as a kitchen.

Capacity and storage

Capacity is the headline difference between the two sides. The BR1460HW lists 14.6 cu ft without an ice maker, while the BUC1700XS lists 17 cu ft. The 17 cu ft example is the roomier of the two, and its listing points to families requiring extra storage.

Inside, the two use different shelf styles. The BR1460HW has a wire freezer shelf that is removable to make space for larger items. The BUC1700XS has glass shelves, which suit wide trays and tall containers that a wire shelf may not hold steady. Neither listing states how many shelves each unit carries, so check the maker description before ordering if shelf count matters to you.

Controls and frost-free care

The BR1460HW uses adjustable temperature control for the refrigerator and the top freezer sections, so each section can be set to its own cooling level. It also has frost-free auto-defrost, which keeps the interior free from ice build-up without manual defrosting.

The BUC1700XS uses electronic control with an LED display, which the maker describes as precise temperature control in freezer and refrigerator mode. Its frost free technology also removes the need for manual defrosting. The BR1460HW adds Sabbath Mode, which pauses settings, displays and sounds; the BUC1700XS listing does not state that mode.

Size, weight and placement

The BR1460HW lists 26.3 by 27.9 by 66.0 inch dimensions and a 134.2 pound weight, in a white finish. The BUC1700XS lists 31.9 by 28.0 by 68.1 inch dimensions and a 165.3 pound weight, in a Stainless Steel Look finish. The 17 cu ft example is wider and heavier, so it needs more floor space and more help moving it into place. Our sizes of upright freezers guide shows how upright units compare on dimensions and capacity.

Listing gaps to check

Both listings state a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty and Energy Star standing, so neither side wins on those points. The BR1460HW listing does not state a convertible mode or glass shelves, and the BUC1700XS listing does not state a top freezer layout, a wire shelf or Sabbath Mode. The BR1460HW size is given as 14.6 cu ft without an ice maker, so shoppers who want ice making should look elsewhere.

Which should you choose?

Choose the 14.6 cu ft BR1460HW if you want a standard top freezer refrigerator for a kitchen, with adjustable temperature control and a removable wire freezer shelf. It is the lighter and narrower of the two, at 134.2 pounds and 26.3 inches wide.

Choose the 17 cu ft BUC1700XS if you want more room, glass shelves and a unit that converts between freezer and refrigerator, with garage ready placement. Compare garage options in our best garage refrigerator guide, and see chest freezer vs upright freezer if you are still weighing the upright shape.

Whichever you pick, measure the space first: the BUC1700XS lists 31.9 inches of width and the BR1460HW lists 26.3 inches, and both need room for the door to swing clear.

In the Preserving Kitchen

  • Sort the harvest into fresh and frozen before buying, so you know whether the convertible BUC1700XS or the fixed top freezer BR1460HW fits the load.
  • Set the adjustable temperature control on the BR1460HW and the electronic control on the BUC1700XS before loading a full harvest.
  • Wipe the glass shelves of the BUC1700XS and the wire freezer shelf of the BR1460HW before the first full load of the season.
  • Keep the removable wire shelf of the BR1460HW with the unit, so larger items still fit when the freezer fills up.
  • Check the frost-free sections of each unit for ice build-up as the season goes on, and use Sabbath Mode on the BR1460HW only as the maker describes it.

How the Harvest Score played out

Product Harvest Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
BLACK+DECKER BUC1700XS 17 9.7 30 21 20 7 4
BLACK+DECKER BR1460HW 14.6 9.7 29 21 21 7 4

Harvest Scores sit on a narrow band from 9.2 up to 9.8. Each tool’s weighted points are converted onto it proportionally, and a higher total always gives a higher number.

The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For cold storage, safety covers the stated features that keep food cold and steady: adjustable temperature control and frost-free auto-defrost on the BR1460HW, and electronic control with an LED display plus frost free technology on the BUC1700XS. The BUC1700XS scores higher on performance for its convertible design and glass shelves, while the BR1460HW scores higher on value for its smaller footprint. Both state a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty. How we pick explains the weights.

FAQ: preserving at home

Can the 17 cu ft BLACK+DECKER work as a refrigerator?

Yes. The BUC1700XS listing describes a convertible design that changes into a full size refrigerator, with glass shelves and an LED display for control in freezer and refrigerator mode.

Which model is garage ready?

The 17 cu ft BUC1700XS is listed as garage ready. The 14.6 cu ft BR1460HW is described for kitchens in homes and apartments, and its listing does not state garage readiness.

How much does each model weigh?

The BR1460HW example weighs 134.2 pounds and the BUC1700XS example weighs 165.3 pounds, as stated in each listing.

What warranty comes with each model?

Each listing states a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty.

More preserving guides

See every cold storage guide and all food storage guides.

More picks: garage refrigerators, upright deep freezers, chest vs upright freezers and what an upright freezer is.

Read next in the kitchen