On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Butter Bell Denim Blue Crock9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Butter Bell White Linen Crock9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Kilner Butter Churn9.6/10View on Amazon
The butter bell vs butter churn choice comes down to a simple question: do you want to keep butter soft on the counter, or make it fresh from cream? A butter bell stores butter under a water seal, while a butter churn turns cream into butter by hand. This comparison looks at listings on each side, strictly at what each listing publishes.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose a butter bell if the goal is spreadable butter on the counter; the Butter Bell Denim Blue example holds exactly one stick (1/2 cup/125g) under a water seal, with no refrigeration needed. Choose a butter churn if the goal is fresh butter from cream; the Kilner example makes 1/2 cup butter per 10.1 oz whipping cream in as little as 10 minutes. The two sides do different jobs, so many kitchens could use both: one to make butter, one to keep it soft.
What made the list
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Butter Bell Denim Blue Crock | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Butter Bell White Linen Crock | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Kilner Butter Churn | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Butter Bell Denim Blue Crock
A New Bone China butter crock with a Denim Blue reactive glaze and a two-piece water seal that keeps one stick of butter spreadable on the countertop.
Pros
- Two-piece water seal keeps butter spreadable with no refrigeration needed
- New Bone China ceramic fired at 2200°F with lead-free, cadmium-free glazes
- Holds exactly one stick (1/2 cup/125g) of salted, unsalted, European or homemade butter
- Reactive Denim Blue glaze gives each crock unique blue tones
Cons
- Stores butter only; it does not make butter from cream
- One-stick capacity means frequent refills for heavy butter use
- Spec table lists both Dishwasher Safe and Hand Wash Only, so care is unclear
- At 1.7 pounds it is heavier than the 1.4 pound White Linen crock

Butter Bell White Linen Crock
A New Bone China butter crock with a White Linen raised relief finish and a two-piece water seal that keeps one stick of butter spreadable on the countertop.
Pros
- Two-piece water seal keeps butter spreadable with no refrigeration needed
- New Bone China ceramic fired at 2200°F with lead-free, cadmium-free glazes
- Holds exactly one stick (1/2 cup/125g) of salted, unsalted, European or homemade butter
- White Linen raised relief antique finish with a Floral pattern
Cons
- Stores butter only; it does not make butter from cream
- One-stick capacity means frequent refills for heavy butter use
- Shares capacity, warranty and materials with the Denim Blue crock, so it adds no new function
- No lid or base spare is listed; the listing names only Crock and Lid as included components

Kilner Butter Churn
A manual butter churn with a 34 fluid oz glass jar, metal gears, a silicone paddle and a wooden grip that turns heavy or whipping cream into butter.
Pros
- Makes a batch of butter in as little as 10 minutes from heavy or whipping cream
- Makes 1/2 cup butter per 10.1 oz whipping cream
- Metal gears with a silicone paddle and a wooden grip and churning handle
- Classic Kilner glass jar with an embossed logo, holding up to 34 fluid oz
Cons
- Hand wash only
- No warranty term is stated
- Makes butter only in small batches: 1/2 cup butter per batch from 10.1 oz cream
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain French Ceramic Butter KeeperCheck price on Amazon
Zulay Kitchen Bell Shaped Butter Crock with Lid forCheck price on Amazon
Ceramic White Butter Crock with Bell-shaped Lid FeaturesCheck price on Amazon
Ceramic Butter Crock with Bell-shaped LidCheck price on Amazon
IFOLO Electric Butter ChurnCheck price on Amazon
Butter ChurnCheck price on Amazon
Butter bell vs butter churn: side by side
| Butter Tool | Harvest Score | Side | Capacity | Material | Care | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butter Bell Denim Blue Crock | 9.7/10 | Butter bell | 125 g | New Bone China ceramic | Dishwasher Safe, Hand Wash Only | View on Amazon |
| Butter Bell White Linen Crock | 9.7/10 | Butter bell | 125 g | New Bone China ceramic | Dishwasher Safe | View on Amazon |
| Kilner Butter Churn | 9.6/10 | Butter churn | 34 fluid oz | Glass, metal, silicone | Hand Wash Only | View on Amazon |
Numbers in this comparison come from the maker as the listing shows them, checked 24 October 2026.
What each side is for
A butter bell is storage. The Butter Bell crocks hold butter under a water seal so it stays fresh and spreadable on the countertop, with no refrigeration needed. A butter churn is a maker. The Kilner churn turns heavy or whipping cream into butter by hand, using a glass jar, metal gears, a silicone paddle and a wooden grip. Neither side replaces the other: the crocks cannot turn cream into butter, and the churn does not store butter under a water seal.
The butter bell setup is a short routine from the listing: add 1/3 cup cold water to the base, pack softened butter firmly into the lid, and insert for the seal. The churn routine is just as short on paper: add heavy or whipping cream and churn until butter forms, with a batch taking as little as 10 minutes. The harvest and processing section groups every tool guide of this kind in one place.
Capacity and size
Both Butter Bell crocks hold exactly one stick (1/2 cup/125g) of salted, unsalted, European or homemade butter, and both list the same 3.94 by 3.94 by 4.13 inch dimensions. The Denim Blue example weighs 1.7 pounds and the White Linen example weighs 1.4 pounds, so the White Linen crock is the lighter of the two on the counter. One stick is a modest amount, so a household that spreads butter daily will refill often.
The Kilner churn holds up to 34 fluid oz in its glass jar and makes 1/2 cup butter per 10.1 oz whipping cream. The crock capacity and the churn capacity use different units, so they do not compare directly: one is a storage amount, the other is a jar volume with a per-batch yield. On size, the churn bullets state a 4 inch diameter, a 7 inch jar height and a 10.5 inch full height including the handle, which is taller than either crock.
Materials and care
The Butter Bell crocks are New Bone China ceramic, fired at 2200°F with lead-free, cadmium-free glazes, and the Denim Blue glaze is reactive, so each crock has unique blue tones. The White Linen crock has a raised relief antique finish with a Floral pattern instead. Both crocks list Dishwasher Safe care in some form, but the Denim Blue spec table lists both Dishwasher Safe and Hand Wash Only, so its care line is unclear.
The Kilner churn mixes materials: a glass jar with an embossed logo, metal gears, a silicone paddle and a wooden grip and churning handle. The listing states BPA free and Hand Wash Only, so the churn needs hand washing while the crocks are the easier care option on paper. Neither churn care note nor crock care note mentions a spare part, and only the crocks state a warranty term.
Listing gaps to check
Three gaps matter before buying. The Kilner listing states no warranty term, while both Butter Bell listings state a 2-year limited warranty. The Denim Blue spec table contradicts itself on care, listing both Dishwasher Safe and Hand Wash Only. The Kilner dimensions also disagree between the bullets and the spec table, with the bullets stating a 4 inch diameter, 7 inch jar height and 10.5 inch full height against a spec table of 4.33 x 10.63 x 6.3 inches. In each case the title and bullets were trusted over the spec table, and the unclear figures are flagged rather than settled.
How to choose the best butter bell vs butter churn
Start from the job: store or make
Pick the side that matches the job. If butter is already bought and the problem is hard butter from the fridge, a butter bell solves it: the Butter Bell examples keep one stick spreadable under a water seal. If the goal is fresh butter from cream, only the churn side works, and the Kilner example makes 1/2 cup butter per 10.1 oz whipping cream. Buyers who want both jobs covered need one of each, since no listing here does both.
Check capacity and counter space
One stick (1/2 cup/125g) is the whole crock capacity, so measure the habit, not just the crock: a household that uses butter daily will refill a butter bell often. The Kilner churn jar holds up to 34 fluid oz, but each batch yields 1/2 cup butter, so it suits small fresh batches rather than bulk making. Compare churn shapes in the butter churn for mason jar guide before settling on a jar style.
Read the care line before buying
Care differs by side. The Kilner churn is Hand Wash Only, so it needs hand washing after every batch. The Butter Bell crocks list dishwasher-safe care in the bullets, but the Denim Blue spec table adds Hand Wash Only, so hand washing is the cautious reading for that crock. Shoppers who want a maker for everyday home use can also compare the butter maker for home guide for other maker styles.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Sort butter making from butter storage before buying: a churn makes butter, a crock keeps it spreadable.
- Set up a butter bell as the listing states: add 1/3 cup cold water to the base, pack softened butter firmly into the lid, and insert for the seal.
- Wash the Kilner churn by hand, since the listing states Hand Wash Only, and keep its glass jar, metal gears, silicone paddle and wooden grip together.
- Read the Denim Blue care line with care: the spec table lists both Dishwasher Safe and Hand Wash Only, so hand washing is the cautious reading.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butter Bell Denim Blue Crock | 9.7 | 30 | 22 | 21 | 7 | 4 |
| Butter Bell White Linen Crock | 9.7 | 29 | 22 | 21 | 7 | 4 |
| Kilner Butter Churn | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 20 | 5 | 0 |
Harvest Scores sit on a narrow band from 9.2 up to 9.8. Each tool’s weighted points are converted onto it proportionally, and a higher total always gives a higher number.
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For butter tools, safety covers the stated materials that touch food: the lead-free, cadmium-free glazes on the Butter Bell crocks and the BPA free listing on the Kilner churn. The two Butter Bell crocks score higher on warranty for their stated 2-year limited warranty, while the Kilner churn earns no warranty points because it states no term. The Kilner churn scores well on performance for making butter in as little as 10 minutes, but its unclear dimensions and hand wash only care hold its build and value scores down. How we pick explains the weights.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can a butter bell make butter?
No. A butter bell stores butter under a water seal so it stays spreadable. Making butter from cream needs a churn, like the Kilner example.
How much butter does a Butter Bell crock hold?
Exactly one stick (1/2 cup/125g) of salted, unsalted, European or homemade butter, for both the Denim Blue and White Linen crocks.
How much butter does the Kilner churn make?
It makes 1/2 cup butter per 10.1 oz whipping cream, with a batch taking as little as 10 minutes.
Do the Butter Bell crocks need refrigeration?
No. The water seal keeps butter fresh and spreadable with no refrigeration needed.
Is the Kilner churn dishwasher safe?
No. The listing states Hand Wash Only for the Kilner churn.
More preserving guides
See every butter churns guide and all harvest and processing guides.
More picks: butter churn for mason jar, butter maker for home, butter bell crock and butter churns.





