Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Canning vs Pickling: Which One Should You Buy?
Canning

Canning vs Pickling: Which One Should You Buy?

Canning is heat processing for shelf-stable jars; pickling is brine preservation. How they differ, where they overlap, and the figures the listings state.

On this page

The cucumbers are piled on the counter and the jars are waiting, but the words on the packets do not agree. Canning vs pickling is the question behind that pile, and the short answer is this: canning is preserving food in heat-processed sealed jars, and pickling is preserving food in a brine, usually vinegar. Pickles are often canned, but pickling is the recipe and canning is the method. This guide explains each step by step.

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Canning vs pickling: the short answer

Canning makes food shelf-stable through heat. Jars are filled, sealed and processed in a water bath or pressure canner, and the heat does the preserving. Pickling makes food sour and crisp through brine: salt, vinegar and spices, with optional crisping agents. A jar of pickles can be canned for the shelf or simply refrigerated, but the pickling is what makes it a pickle.

Method What it is Needs heat processing Key ingredients
Canning Heat-processed sealed jars Yes, water bath or pressure Jars, lids, canner tools
Pickling Brine preservation Only if you can the pickles Salt, vinegar, spices, lime or crisp granules

What canning is

Canning is a method, not a recipe. Food goes into jars, the jars are sealed and heated, and the result keeps on the shelf. The LEONICE starter kit (on Amazon) shows the tools involved: a jar lifter, a funnel that fits regular and wide-mouth jars, a 3-in-1 lid lifter and bubble remover, tongs and 24 jar labels, all in food-grade stainless steel at 1.39 pounds, listed for water bath and pressure canners. The kit’s own bullets advise processing jars of the same size in each batch.

If you are learning, books help. The Ball Back to Basics guide is an illustrated edition from July 4, 2017 at 2.31 pounds, covering jams, jellies and pickles. The Homestead Canning Cookbook lists 150+ recipes for water bath and pressure canning from January 7, 2020. For gear, see our canning funnels for wide-mouth jars.

What pickling is

Pickling is a recipe: cucumbers (or tomatoes, watermelon rinds and more, per the Mrs. Wages listings) plus brine plus crunch. The listings give the figures:

  • Pickling lime: Mrs. Wages lists a 1-pound resealable bag of food-grade calcium hydroxide, kosher certified, made in the USA, for extra-crisp pickles.
  • Xtra Crunch: Mrs. Wages lists a 5.5-ounce jar added to each jar of pickles with no rinsing or soaking, as a quicker route than pickling lime; the listing gives 1/8 tsp (0.6g) per pint.
  • Pickling salt: Morton lists a fine-grain all-natural salt made for canning, pickling, marinating and brining, in a 4-pound box or a 4-pack of 4-pound packs.
  • Pickling spice: McCormick Culinary lists a 12-ounce container with a blend of 11 spices, kosher and made without added MSG.
  • Pickle Crisp granules: Ball lists a 5.5-ounce jar that makes 80 quarts of crunchy pickles.

Where they overlap

Most home pickles are both pickled and canned: the brine makes them pickles, the heat processing makes them shelf-stable. That is why Morton calls its salt “Canning & Pickling Salt” and why the Ball book covers jams, jellies and pickles together. If you pickle without canning, the jars live in the refrigerator; if you can without pickling, you get plain preserved food. For jars that suit pickles, see our canning jars for pickles.

Read the listing twice

The listings are consistent on ingredients but sloppy in places:

  • Mrs. Wages 6-pack: the title says pickling lime while the bullets say the bags contain “Mrs. Wages Pickling Salt”; lime and salt are different products, so confirm before buying.
  • McCormick: the title states 12 ounces while the spec table states an item weight of 14.4 ounces.
  • Mrs. Wages pickling lime: the warranty description reads only “Warranty”, which states nothing useful.

In the Preserving Kitchen

  • Start with a current canning book before your first batch; the Ball and Homestead books are the references here.
  • Measure Xtra Crunch per the listing: 1/8 tsp (0.6g) per pint, with no rinsing or soaking.
  • Use fine-grain pickling salt, not table salt, for clear brine.
  • Keep pickling lime and pickling salt apart; the 6-pack listing mixes up the two.

FAQ: preserving at home

What is canning or pickling salt?

Morton Canning & Pickling Salt is a fine-grain all-natural salt made for canning, pickling, marinating and brining. The listings state a 4-pound box and a 4-pack of 4-pound packs.

How long does canned food last?

The listings do not state a shelf life, so this guide gives no number. Check a current canning book for storage guidance.

Do I need pickling lime or Xtra Crunch?

Both aim at crisp pickles. Pickling lime is food-grade calcium hydroxide in a 1-pound bag. Xtra Crunch is a 5.5-ounce jar added to each jar of pickles with no rinsing or soaking.

What equipment do I need to start canning?

The LEONICE starter kit lists a jar lifter, funnel, lid lifter, bubble remover, tongs and 24 jar labels at 1.39 pounds, for water bath and pressure canners.

More preserving guides

See every canning guide and all water bath canners guides.

More picks: canning jars for pickles, canning funnels for wide-mouth jars and canning.

Read next in the kitchen