On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
SHALL Hori Hori 7-Inch9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Fiskars 3-Piece Garden Set9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Grand Way Hori Hori 7-Inch9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
MECHEER 2-Pack Garden Trowels9.4/10View on Amazon
The hori hori vs trowel choice comes down to the job: slicing through roots, or scooping and moving soil. A hori hori is a garden knife with straight and serrated edges, while a trowel is a small scoop for digging and transplanting.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose a hori hori for a knife that digs, weeds, cuts roots and measures planting depth; the SHALL example has a 7 inch blade with a 6 inch scale. Choose a trowel for a scoop that moves soil and transplants seedlings; the Fiskars example is a 3-piece set with a lifetime warranty. A gardener who does both jobs needs both tools.
What made the list
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | SHALL Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Fiskars 3-Piece Garden Set | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Grand Way Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | MECHEER 2-Pack Garden Trowels | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |

SHALL Hori Hori 7-Inch
A 7 inch stainless steel hori hori with a rosewood handle, a 6 inch measurement scale and a leather sheath, for digging, weeding and cutting roots.
Pros
- 7 inch stainless steel blade with straight, serrated and rope cutting edges
- 6 inch measurement scale on the blade for planting depth
- Full-tang rosewood handle with 3 rivets and a handguard
- Leather sheath with 7 rivets, a belt loop and a metal snap
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- The listing states only the 7 inch blade length
- The 6 inch scale stops short of the 7 inch blade tip
- Single knife only, with no extra tool included

Fiskars 3-Piece Garden Set
A 3-piece set with a trowel, a transplanter and a cultivator, with cast-aluminum heads, SoftGrip handles and a lifetime warranty.
Pros
- 3 tools in one set: trowel, transplanter and cultivator
- Cast-aluminum heads and tines for digging in tough soil
- SoftGrip ergonomic handles for control and less fatigue
- Lifetime warranty is stated
Cons
- No separate weight is stated for the trowel alone
- No blade or tine length is stated
- No sheath or storage case is stated
- Heads are cast aluminum rather than steel

Grand Way Hori Hori 7-Inch
A 7 inch stainless steel hori hori with a serrated edge, a weeding fork and a rubberized handle, for digging, planting and weeding.
Pros
- 7 inch stainless steel blade with straight and serrated edges
- Built-in weeding fork for weed and root removal
- Rubber coated handle for grip in wet or muddy conditions
- Crossguard and belt-loop sheath for storage and carrying
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No weight is stated
- No measurement scale is stated on the blade
- Handle is plastic with a rubber coating rather than wood

MECHEER 2-Pack Garden Trowels
A 2-pack of wide garden trowels in aluminum alloy, one with inch and centimeter scales and TPR handles, for digging, planting and transplanting.
Pros
- 2 trowels in a pack for digging and transplanting
- One trowel has inch and centimeter scales for planting depth
- Aluminum alloy body that the maker calls rust-resistant
- TPR handles with finger grips and a palm rest
Cons
- Only one of the two trowels has measurement scales
- No sheath or storage case is stated
- No blade length is stated
- 2 trowels only, with no transplanter or cultivator
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
WORKPRO Garden Trowel with Wood HandleCheck price on Amazon
Sengreen Hori Digging KnifeCheck price on Amazon
SUMIO 13.3" Alloy Steel Weeding TransplanterCheck price on Amazon
Ferry Morse Hori Hori Knife & Trowel ComboCheck price on Amazon
Gardening Hori Hori Garden KnifeCheck price on Amazon
Barebones Hori Hori Ultimate Garden KnifeCheck price on Amazon
Hori hori vs trowel: side by side
| Garden Tool | Harvest Score | Side | Blade or Head | Handle | Sheath or Set | Warranty | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SHALL Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6/10 | Hori hori | 7 inch stainless steel blade | Rosewood, full tang | Leather sheath | Not stated | View on Amazon |
| Fiskars 3-Piece Garden Set | 9.6/10 | Trowel | Cast-aluminum trowel head | SoftGrip | 3-piece set | Lifetime warranty | View on Amazon |
| Grand Way Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6/10 | Hori hori | 7 inch stainless steel blade | Rubberized | Belt-loop sheath | Not stated | View on Amazon |
| MECHEER 2-Pack Garden Trowels | 9.4/10 | Trowel | Aluminum alloy trowel | Non-slip TPR | 2-pack | Not stated | View on Amazon |
We list the manufacturer’s stated figures without changes, as of 19 November 2026.
What each tool is for
The hori hori examples are knives: a straight edge for clean cuts, a serrated edge for sawing roots and compact soil, and a weeding fork on the Grand Way example. Both state a 7 inch blade, and the SHALL example adds a rope cutting edge and a 6 inch measurement scale. The trowel examples are scoops: the Fiskars set holds a trowel, a transplanter and a cultivator, and the MECHEER set holds 2 trowels.
The jobs overlap on digging and planting, and split on cutting and moving. A hori hori cuts roots and rope and measures depth with its blade, while a trowel moves soil and lifts seedlings with its scoop. The Grand Way example covers digging, planting, weeding, cutting roots, transplanting and measuring soil depth, and the MECHEER example covers planting, transplanting, weeding and removing small trees. Neither side claims the other side’s job, so the choice follows the work.
Blade length, handles and sheaths
Blade length is the same on both hori hori examples at 7 inches. The SHALL example states more figures: 11-7/8 inches overall, a blade thickness of 3/32 inch, a handle length of 4-7/8 inches and a weight of 9.5 ounces. The Grand Way example states no weight and no handle length.
Handles split the hori hori examples: rosewood with 3 rivets on the SHALL example, and a rubberized plastic handle on the Grand Way example. The Fiskars set uses SoftGrip ergonomic handles on all 3 tools, and the MECHEER set uses non-slip TPR handles with finger grips and a palm rest. Sheaths split them too: leather with a metal snap on the SHALL example, and a belt-loop sheath on the Grand Way example. Neither trowel example states a sheath; the MECHEER example hangs by the hole in its handle.
Sets, packs and warranty
The trowel side sells in sets: the Fiskars example is a 3-piece set with a trowel, a transplanter and a cultivator, and the MECHEER example is a 2-pack of different trowels. The hori hori side sells a knife on its own, with a sheath on both examples. A gardener who wants several tools at once gets more from the trowel side.
Warranty separates the examples. The Fiskars example states a lifetime warranty, and no other example states a warranty term. A lifetime warranty covers the whole Fiskars set, so it counts for the trowel, the transplanter and the cultivator alike.
Listing gaps to check
The SHALL knife carries two different weights and two different overall lengths; check before ordering. The Grand Way knife states no weight, so it cannot be compared with the SHALL example. The MECHEER trowels state no blade length. The Fiskars set states the weight of the whole set, 1.45 pounds, with no weight for the trowel alone.
How to choose the best hori hori vs trowel
Choose a hori hori if you cut roots and measure depth
Pick a hori hori when the work is cutting: the serrated edge saws through roots and compact soil, and the straight edge makes clean cuts. The SHALL example adds a rope cutting edge and a 6 inch scale for planting depth; the Grand Way example adds a weeding fork. A hori hori also digs planting holes. Keep the blade sharp between seasons; a whetstone vs knife sharpener guide covers sharpening tools.
Choose a trowel if you move soil and transplant
Pick a trowel when the work is moving soil: the scoop lifts and drops soil, while a knife blade cuts. The transplanter in the Fiskars set is shaped for seedlings, and the cultivator turns soil. A trowel cannot cut roots the way a serrated hori hori can, so keep a knife close when roots block the bed. Carry the harvest home in a basket; harvest basket ideas gather options for the trip to the kitchen.
Check the sheath, the set and the warranty
Before ordering, check what comes with the tool: a sheath with both hori hori examples, a 3-piece Fiskars set, and a 2-pack from MECHEER. Check the warranty too: the Fiskars example states a lifetime warranty, and the other examples state none. Check weight and blade length too: the SHALL example states 9.5 ounces and a 7 inch blade, while the Grand Way example states no weight.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Store the SHALL knife in its leather sheath, snap fastened, and hang it by the hide rope.
- Carry the Grand Way knife in its belt-loop sheath, crossguard between hand and blade.
- Hang the MECHEER trowels by the hole in the handle, scales facing out.
- Keep the Fiskars trowel, transplanter and cultivator together.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SHALL Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6 | 30 | 22 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| Fiskars 3-Piece Garden Set | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 21 | 0 | 4 |
| Grand Way Hori Hori 7-Inch | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| MECHEER 2-Pack Garden Trowels | 9.4 | 28 | 20 | 20 | 0 | 0 |
Shown scores begin at 9.2 and stop at 9.8. Where a pick lands depends only on its weighted total: more points, never a lower result.
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For garden tools, safety covers the stated features that keep the hand off the blade: the crossguard on the Grand Way example, the handguard on the SHALL example, and sheaths that cover the blade in storage. The SHALL example scores highest on build for its stated figures, while the Fiskars example scores highest on value and warranty for its 3 tools and lifetime warranty. The MECHEER example scores lowest for its thin stated figures and no stated warranty.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can a hori hori replace a trowel?
For digging and planting, partly: both hori hori examples dig and plant. For moving soil and transplanting seedlings, a trowel scoop is the tool for the job, and the Fiskars set adds a transplanter.
What blade length do the hori hori examples state?
Both state a 7 inch blade; the SHALL example adds a 6 inch measurement scale, while the Grand Way example states no scale.
Do the trowel examples state a warranty?
The Fiskars example states a lifetime warranty for its 3-piece set; the MECHEER example states no warranty term.
Which hori hori has a measurement scale?
The SHALL example has a 6 inch measurement scale on its blade for planting depth; the Grand Way example states no scale.
More preserving guides
See every garden harvest tools guide and all harvest and processing guides.
More picks: electric garden carts, folding wagons vs garden carts, garden dump carts and nut gatherers vs nut harvesters.





