On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Avery Round Printable Labels9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
SUPVAN E10 Bluetooth Label Maker with 3 Tapes9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Avery Printable Round Labels9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Avery Printable Square LabelsView on Amazon - 5
Avery® Printable Round LabelsView on Amazon - 6
NATURALABEL Kraft Labels for Laser & Inkjet PrintersView on Amazon
A pantry shelf of unlabeled jars is a guessing game, so the printable labels vs label maker question comes down to volume: printable labels win for batch labeling with a home printer, while a label maker wins for one-off labels on demand. All four listings we compared are printable label sheets, so this guide compares the two ideas and then ranks the actual gear on size, count and printer type.
Runners-up to consider
Avery Printable Square LabelsCheck price on Amazon
Avery® Printable Round LabelsCheck price on Amazon
NATURALABEL Kraft Labels for Laser & Inkjet PrintersCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Printable labels vs label maker: the short answer
Printable labels win for jars, boxes and pantry goods in batches: you design once in software and print a whole sheet. A label maker wins for single labels printed on the spot, like a price tag at a market stall. The listings here are all printable sheets: two Avery Easy Peel address label listings, a TownStix 4 by 5 inch sheet pack and a 500-count 4 by 6 inch direct thermal roll. None of the four is a label maker, which tells you what the market sells for this job.
If you want a label maker instead, our best label maker for canning jars roundup covers the other side of this choice.
The gear: four printable label listings compared
| Listing | Label size | Count | Printer type |
|---|---|---|---|
| TownStix 4×5 | 4 x 5 in | 120 labels, 30 sheets | Laser or inkjet |
| Avery Easy Peel 1×2-5/8 | 1 x 2-5/8 in | Not stated | Inkjet |
| Avery Easy Peel 1×2-5/8 | 1 x 2-5/8 in | Not stated | Not stated |
| 9527 Product 4×6 thermal | 4 x 6 in | 500 labels | Direct thermal |
TownStix 4×5, 30 sheets
The TownStix listing ships 30 sheets of large white labels at 4 by 5 inches per label, 120 labels total, on 8.5 by 11 inch sheets. The listing states laser and inkjet printing, a matte surface that prevents ink smudges, a writable surface like paper, self-adhesive backing, and downloadable print templates in PDF and Word. The biggest label size and the template detail give it the top rank.
Avery Easy Peel 1×2-5/8, inkjet
The Avery listing B00004Z5SM is the classic address label: 1 by 2-5/8 inches, white, for inkjet printers. The listing states patented Sure Feed technology to reduce misalignments and printer jams, and an Easy Peel pop-up edge that lifts the label edges for quick peeling. The listing also points to Avery Design and Print Online for designing the labels. The brand detail and the feed technology put it second.
Avery Easy Peel 1×2-5/8
The Avery listing B00006B8FZ is the same Easy Peel address label shape: 1 by 2-5/8 inches, white, with Sure Feed technology and the Easy Peel pop-up edge, plus Avery Design and Print Online. The listing states no printer type, which is the only stated difference from its sibling, so it ranks third.
9527 Product 4×6 direct thermal, 500 labels
The 9527 Product listing is the odd one: 500 direct thermal labels at 4 by 6 inches in a fanfold stack with a perforated line, white. The listing states a thicker backing paper for smoother printing and strong adhesive for corrugated boxes and envelopes, and notes the paper should be stored dry, dark and ventilated. Direct thermal needs a thermal printer and no ink, which suits shipping labels rather than jars, so it ranks fourth.
What the listings agree on
Every listing is a white, self-adhesive label for printing at home. Sizes run from 1 by 2-5/8 inches to 4 by 6 inches, and counts run from 120 labels to 500. None of the four states a price, a review count or a warranty term, so the ranking rests on stated size, count and printer detail.
Size and printer type
Pick the size by the jar: the 4 by 5 inch TownStix suits big pantry jars, the 1 by 2-5/8 inch Avery suits address-size jar lids, and the 4 by 6 inch thermal suits shipping boxes. Match the printer type to your machine: laser or inkjet for the TownStix, inkjet for the stated Avery, and a thermal printer for the 9527 roll. For jar-specific label designs, our best canning labels for pickles guide covers food-ready options.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers printable label sheets only. It does not cover label maker machines or label printers beyond the comparison link above, and it does not cover waterproof label claims: check the listing before labeling anything that lives in the fridge.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can I use these on canning jars?
The listings describe general-purpose labels for paper, plastic and cardboard. For jar-specific labels, see our canning label guides linked above.
Which label is biggest?
The 9527 Product at 4 by 6 inches, followed by the TownStix at 4 by 5 inches. The Avery labels are 1 by 2-5/8 inches.
Do I need a special printer?
The TownStix states laser or inkjet, one Avery states inkjet, and the 9527 roll needs a direct thermal printer.
How many labels per pack?
The TownStix gives 120 labels on 30 sheets, the 9527 gives 500 labels, and the Avery listings state no count.
More preserving guides
See every canning label guide and all canning guides.
More picks: canning labels for hot sauce, canning labels for syrup and canning labels for spices.





