Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Silicone vs Stainless Steel Dehydrator Trays: Which to Buy?
Food Dehydrators

Silicone vs Stainless Steel Dehydrator Trays: Which to Buy?

Silicone vs stainless steel dehydrator trays compared on four listings: raised-edge silicone liners against 304 stainless mesh trays, and who each side fits.

On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 inAulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Aulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 inAulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 in9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Baderke 4-Pack Steel TraysBaderke 4-Pack Steel Trays9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Baderke 2-Pack Steel TraysBaderke 2-Pack Steel Trays9.5/10View on Amazon

A counter full of sliced apples is the moment most dehydrator owners start wondering whether their trays are the right ones. The silicone vs stainless steel dehydrator trays choice comes down to what you dry: silicone sheets are liners that catch juices for fruit leather and jerky, while stainless steel trays are the drying racks themselves. We compared two listings of each side, going strictly by what each Amazon listing publishes.

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: choose silicone if you make fruit leather, fruit rolls or jerky and want a non-stick liner with a raised lip that holds liquids; the Aulock 13.7-inch example withstands -40°F to 446°F and fits Cosori, Excalibur and Magic Mill 14-inch trays. Choose stainless steel if you need replacement drying trays for your dehydrator; the Baderke 4-pack example is 304 stainless at 12.99 by 12.01 inches and fits the CP267-FD only.

Two sides, four examples

Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in

Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in

Aulock9.6/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Six raised-edge silicone sheets at 13.7 by 13.7 inches, for fruit leather and jerky on 14-inch metal trays.

Pros

  • Raised lip keeps juices and fruit leather mix on the sheet
  • Withstands -40°F to 446°F, usable in dehydrators and ovens per the listing
  • Food grade silicone, BPA free, non-stick and reusable
  • Fits Cosori, Excalibur and Magic Mill 14-inch trays

Cons

  • Cannot be used alone; must sit on a hard tray
  • Soft silicone can change shape when moved with food on it
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Confirm your tray size before ordering; the listing warns against ordering by mistake
Aulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 in

Aulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 in

Aulock9.5/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Six raised-edge silicone sheets at about 11.8 by 10.6 inches, shaped for Cosori 12 by 11 inch trays.

Pros

  • Raised lip keeps juices and fruit leather mix on the sheet
  • Withstands -40°F to 446°F, usable in dehydrators and ovens per the listing
  • Food grade silicone, BPA free, non-stick and reusable
  • Shaped for Cosori 12 by 11 inch trays

Cons

  • Cannot be used alone; must sit on a hard tray
  • Soft silicone can change shape when moved with food on it
  • No warranty term is stated
Baderke 4-Pack Steel Trays

Baderke 4-Pack Steel Trays

Baderke9.5/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Four 304 stainless steel mesh drying trays at 12.99 by 12.01 inches, replacements that fit the CP267-FD only.

Pros

  • 304 stainless steel mesh stated, a solid step up from plastic racks
  • Four trays per pack for drying several foods without mixing flavors
  • Generous 12.99 by 12.01 inch size per the spec table
  • Stated easy to clean

Cons

  • Fits the CP267-FD only; measure before buying
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Weight of 1.5 pounds does not say if it is one tray or the four-pack
Baderke 2-Pack Steel Trays

Baderke 2-Pack Steel Trays

Baderke9.5/10 Harvest Score
i
The Harvest Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Two 304 stainless steel mesh drying trays at 12.99 by 12.01 inches, replacements that fit the CP267-FD only.

Pros

  • 304 stainless steel mesh stated, a solid step up from plastic racks
  • Two trays for replacing worn racks or adding capacity
  • Generous 12.99 by 12.01 inch size per the spec table
  • Stated easy to clean

Cons

  • Fits the CP267-FD only; measure before buying
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Weight of 12.64 ounces does not say if it is one tray or the two-pack
  • Two trays per pack when the four-pack sibling listing exists

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Runners-up to consider

Silicone vs stainless steel dehydrator trays: side by side

Tray Harvest Score Side Pack size Material Stated size Compatibility Amazon
Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in 9.6/10 Silicone 6 sheets Food grade silicone, BPA free 13.7 x 13.7 in Cosori, Excalibur, Magic Mill 14 in trays View on Amazon
Aulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 in 9.5/10 Silicone 6 sheets Food grade silicone, BPA free 11.8 x 10.6 in Cosori CP267-FD 12 x 11 in trays View on Amazon
Baderke 4-Pack Steel Trays 9.5/10 Stainless steel 4 trays 304 stainless steel 12.99 x 12.01 in CP267-FD only View on Amazon
Baderke 2-Pack Steel Trays 9.5/10 Stainless steel 2 trays 304 stainless steel 12.99 x 12.01 in CP267-FD only View on Amazon

Numbers in this comparison come from the maker as the listing shows them, checked 21 October 2026.

What each side is for

The two sides are not the same item in different materials. The Aulock silicone sheets are liners that sit on top of a hard metal tray; the bullets warn they cannot be used alone because the soft silicone changes shape. They are the pick for anything wet or sticky that would fall through a mesh rack: fruit leather, fruit rolls, hawthorn rolls, jerky and cookies, all named in the listings. The raised edge keeps the mix on the sheet.

The Baderke stainless trays are the drying racks themselves: 304 stainless mesh screens that replace or add to the trays in the dehydrator. They suit fruit, vegetables, meat and herbs dried in the open air flow of the machine. If your harvest is mostly sliced produce with nothing to catch, steel racks are the whole answer; if fruit leather is the plan, you need the liner on top of a rack.

Size and fit

Measure your trays before you order, because both sides are picky about fit. The Aulock 13.7-inch sheets measure 13.7 by 13.7 inches and list Cosori, Excalibur and Magic Mill 14-inch trays; the 11.8-inch sheets suit Cosori 12 by 11 inch trays. The Baderke trays are listed for the CP267-FD only, at 12.99 by 12.01 by 0.2 inches, and the listing says to confirm the fit so the trays seat properly. A figure from one listing describes that listing only: the Baderke 4-pack’s 1.5 pounds and the 2-pack’s 12.64 ounces do not say whether they cover one tray or the pack.

One listing leaves its size unclear. The smaller Aulock sheet shows 11.8 by 10.6 inches in the bullets but 13.7 by 13.7 inches in the spec table’s quantity line, so we trusted the title and bullets for the 11.8-inch figure. The larger Aulock sheet is consistent at 13.7 by 13.7 across bullets and spec table. Our cabinet vs tray food dehydrator comparison helps if you are still choosing the machine itself.

Materials, cleaning and reuse

The Aulock sheets state food grade silicone, BPA free, non-stick, and a -40°F to 446°F range that covers both dehydrator and oven use per the listing. Both silicone listings call the sheets easy to clean and reusable. The Baderke trays state 304 solid stainless steel with a food-safe material feature, and the bullets call cleanup easy because of the stainless material. Neither side states a warranty term, and neither states a third-party certification.

Heat range is the one spec where silicone clearly wins: the Aulock listings state the -40°F to 446°F span, while the Baderke listings state no temperature range at all. For dehydrator use that gap hardly matters, since neither listing suggests temperatures near those limits, but it matters if you plan to use the liner in an oven. See our silicone vs parchment dehydrator sheets guide for the liner side of this decision.

Listing gaps to check

Both sides have listing quirks. The Baderke 4-pack spec table says Number of Items 2 while the title and bullets say 4 trays; we trusted the title and bullets for the count. The smaller Aulock sheet’s spec table borrows the larger sheet’s 13.7-inch figures, as noted above. Neither side states a warranty term, and the weights on all four listings leave the per-item split unclear. In each case we trusted the title and bullets over the spec table.

Which should you choose?

Choose silicone if your drying projects are wet or sticky: fruit leather, fruit rolls, jerky or cookies on a non-stick liner with a raised edge. The Aulock sheets also double as oven mats within their stated -40°F to 446°F range. Compare liner options in our silicone vs parchment dehydrator sheets guide.

Choose stainless steel if you need replacement drying racks for the dehydrator itself and want 304 stainless instead of plastic. Just make sure your machine is the CP267-FD, since both Baderke listings fit that model only. Start with the food dehydrators section to match accessories to your machine.

You can also run both: steel racks for sliced produce, with a silicone liner laid on top for fruit leather batches. That is exactly the pairing the Aulock listings describe, liner on hard tray.

In the Preserving Kitchen

  • Lay silicone sheets on a hard metal tray; the listings state the soft silicone cannot be used alone and changes shape when moved.
  • Match the sheet to the tray: the silicone mat must not be larger than the metal tray it sits on, so confirm the size before ordering.
  • Check the CP267-FD fit for the Baderke trays before buying, since both listings name that model only.
  • Clean trays and sheets after each batch; both sides state easy cleanup, and the silicone sheets are stated reusable.

How the Harvest Score played out

Product Harvest Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in 9.6 29 20 20 7 0
Aulock Silicone Sheets 11.8 in 9.5 28 20 20 7 0
Baderke 4-Pack Steel Trays 9.5 28 21 20 6 0
Baderke 2-Pack Steel Trays 9.5 27 20 21 6 0

Harvest Scores sit on a narrow band from 9.2 up to 9.8. Each tool’s weighted points are converted onto it proportionally, and a higher total always gives a higher number.

The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For trays, safety means the stated food-contact materials: food grade silicone with BPA free on the Aulock sheets, and 304 stainless steel with a food-safe feature on the Baderke trays. The Aulock 13.7-inch sheets lead on the stated temperature range and clean size figures, while the two Baderke packs score on the stated 304 stainless build. None of the four earns warranty points because no listing states a term. How we pick explains the weights.

FAQ: preserving at home

Can silicone dehydrator sheets go in the oven?

The Aulock listings state the sheets withstand -40°F to 446°F and can be used in dehydrators and ovens. The Baderke stainless listings state no temperature range.

Can you use silicone sheets without a tray under them?

No. Both Aulock listings warn that the silicone is soft, cannot be used alone, and should be placed on a hard tray before food goes on.

Do the Baderke trays fit every dehydrator?

No. Both Baderke listings state the trays are compatible with the CP267-FD model only, so measure your machine before ordering.

Aulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in
Still deciding? Our top pickAulock Silicone Sheets 13.7 in
Check price on Amazon

More preserving guides

See every Food Dehydrators guide and all Drying guides.

More picks: mylar bags for dehydrated vegetables, mason jars for dehydrated food, dehydrator vs smoker for jerky and cabinet vs tray dehydrators.

Read next in the kitchen