On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Ball Jar Stainless Steel One-Piece Mason Jar LidsView on Amazon - 2
[16 Piece]8 Wide Mouth + 8 Regular Mouth Mason Jar LidsView on Amazon - 3
Norpro Canning Essentials Boxed SetView on Amazon - 4
OXO Good Grips 3-Piece Multi-Purpose Funnel Set Includes 4 ozView on Amazon - 5
2 Pack ONE-PIECE 316 Surgical Stainless Steel Sprouting LidsView on Amazon - 6
6-PackView on Amazon
Single piece vs two piece canning lids comes down to what the jar is for. Choose two-piece lids, a flat lid plus a screw band, for actual canning and preserving: the listings state they seal jars for up to 18 months. Choose one-piece lids for storage, dry goods and fridge use: the Ball one-piece stainless listing states plainly that it is not safe for preserving. Every figure below comes from the reference listings.
Runners-up to consider
Ball Jar Stainless Steel One-Piece Mason Jar LidsCheck price on Amazon
[16 Piece]8 Wide Mouth + 8 Regular Mouth Mason Jar LidsCheck price on Amazon
Norpro Canning Essentials Boxed SetCheck price on Amazon
OXO Good Grips 3-Piece Multi-Purpose Funnel Set Includes 4 ozCheck price on Amazon
2 Pack ONE-PIECE 316 Surgical Stainless Steel Sprouting LidsCheck price on Amazon
6-PackCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Two-piece canning lids
Two-piece lids are the classic canning setup: a flat metal lid with sealing compound plus a reusable screw band that holds it during processing. The Ball regular mouth 12-lid listing states SureTight lids seal up to 18 months, that the sealing material is single-use only, and that the lids are BPA-free; bands are not included. The DSJIFGEW split-type set states 12 lids plus 12 bands for 70mm regular mouth jars, BPA-free silicone seals, seals up to 18 months, and the key detail: rings are reusable while lids are intended for single use. The FZCWAHJK set states 12 sets of stainless steel lids and bands for regular mouth jars, reusable many times. Two-piece is the only style in the listings with stated preserving performance.
One-piece lids
One-piece lids screw on as a single unit and suit storage rather than preserving. The Ball stainless steel one-piece wide mouth lids, 6 count, state they create an airtight seal for keeping contents fresh and are BPA-free, but also state hand-wash only and, crucially, not safe for preserving. The North Mountain Supply one-piece safety button lids, 12 pack in gold for 70mm mouths with a BPA-free plastisol liner, are recommended for hot-fill products, with a note that water bath processing should use hi-heat lids instead. One-piece lids are convenient for spices, dry goods, fridge pickles and pantry storage, but the listings do not back them for shelf-stable canning.
Single piece vs two piece canning lids: head to head
| Aspect | Two-piece (Ball, DSJIFGEW, FZCWAHJK) | One-piece (Ball, North Mountain) |
|---|---|---|
| Safe for preserving | Yes; up to 18 months stated | Ball states not safe for preserving |
| Parts | Flat lid plus screw band | Single screw-on unit |
| Reusability | Bands reusable; lids single use stated | Reusable for storage |
| Seal material | Sealing compound or silicone, stated | Plastisol liner or gasket, stated |
| Sizes stated | 70mm regular mouth | 70mm regular; wide mouth (Ball) |
| Care | Not stated | Ball one-piece: hand-wash only |
Every figure in the table comes from the reference listings. Where a listing states nothing, the table leaves it unclear.
Which should you buy?
Buy two-piece if
- You are water-bath or pressure canning for shelf-stable storage; the listings state seals up to 18 months.
- You want the standard system: flat lids are single use, bands are reusable, per the DSJIFGEW listing.
- You follow USDA-style guidance, which is built around two-piece lids.
Buy one-piece if
- You store dry goods, spices, fridge pickles or leftovers; the Ball one-piece states an airtight seal for freshness.
- You want grab-and-go convenience with no separate band to lose.
- You accept the limit: Ball states its one-piece lids are not safe for preserving.
A note on plastic storage caps
Plastic screw caps are a third category: storage only. The Staruby 24-pack states 70mm regular mouth plastic lids with temperature tolerance up to 240F, dishwasher safe on the top rack. The Bedgeta 9-pack states food-grade PP lids with detachable silicone rings, BPA free and reusable. Neither is a canning lid; use them for the fridge, freezer and pantry, never for processing.
Pair the right lids with the right jars: our best canning jars for salsa and best canning jars for tomato sauce guides cover jar choices.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can one-piece lids be used for canning?
The Ball one-piece stainless listing states not safe for preserving. The North Mountain one-piece is recommended for hot-fill products, with hi-heat lids advised for water bath processing. For shelf-stable canning, use two-piece lids.
Are canning lids reusable?
Bands are reusable; flat lids are single use. The Ball listing states the sealing material is single-use only, and the DSJIFGEW listing states rings are reusable while lids are intended for single use.
How long do sealed jars keep?
Both the Ball SureTight and DSJIFGEW listings state seals up to 18 months. Store sealed jars cool, dark and dry, and check seals before eating.
More preserving guides
See every canning guide. Also see our best canning jars for salsa. Also see our best canning jars for tomato sauce.
More picks: canning.





