On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Aosnttol Glass Fermentation Jar 2.5L9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Gardener's Supply 1-Gallon Stoneware Pickling Crock9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Ohio Stoneware 5-Gallon Preserving Crock Cover9.4/10View on Amazon
Sauerkraut in a crock you cannot see into, or kimchi in a jar you can watch bubble: stoneware vs glass fermentation crock is a choice between tradition and visibility. Stoneware suits bulk ferments kept in the dark; glass suits small batches you want to monitor day by day.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict on stoneware vs glass fermentation crock: choose glass if you want to watch the ferment and want a water seal lid; choose stoneware for traditional bulk fermenting in an opaque crock. Note that one of the three listings here is a crock cover, not a crock: the Ohio Stoneware listing covers a 5-gallon crock rather than being one.
Three examples
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aosnttol Glass Fermentation Jar 2.5L | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Gardener's Supply 1-Gallon Stoneware Pickling Crock | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Ohio Stoneware 5-Gallon Preserving Crock Cover | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Aosnttol Glass Fermentation Jar 2.5L
A 2.5-liter glass fermenting jar with a water seal lid, for small-batch pickles, kimchi and sauerkraut.
Pros
- Water seal lid stated
- 2.5-liter capacity stated
- 12-month warranty stated
- Lead-free glass stated
Cons
- Glass is breakable, per the listing
- Hand wash stated
- 3 pounds for 2.5 liters
- No certification stated

Gardener's Supply 1-Gallon Stoneware Pickling Crock
A 1-gallon lead-free stoneware crock kit with lid, for traditional pickling and fermenting.
Pros
- Lead-free stoneware stated
- Complete kit with lid
- 1-gallon capacity stated
- Vintage look stated
Cons
- Care contradicts: hand wash vs dishwasher safe
- 2 pounds, light for stoneware
- No warranty stated
- No certification stated

Ohio Stoneware 5-Gallon Preserving Crock Cover
A stoneware cover for a 5-gallon preserving crock, not the crock itself.
Pros
- Lead-free, natural stoneware stated
- Oven, microwave and dishwasher safe
- Fits 5-gallon crocks
- Easy to clean stated
Cons
- Cover only, not a crock
- Warranty stated with no term
- 0.27 g weight figure is not usable
- No capacity of its own
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Ohio Stoneware 4 Gallon Preserving Crocks Brand: OhioCheck price on Amazon
Fermentation Crock Jar 10 Liter/2.6 GallonCheck price on Amazon
Ohio Stoneware 5 Gallon Fermentation & Preservation CrockCheck price on Amazon
Fermentation Crock 3.8Liter/1 Gallon Stoneware Pot forCheck price on Amazon
Ohio Stoneware 2 Gallon Crock Brand: Ohio StonewareCheck price on Amazon
Gardener's Supply Company Ohio Stoneware 1GC CrockCheck price on Amazon
Stoneware vs glass fermentation crock: side by side
| Crock | Harvest Score | Side | Capacity | Material | Lid and seal | Warranty | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aosnttol Glass Fermentation Jar 2.5L | 9.6/10 | Glass | 2.5 liters | Glass | Water seal lid | 12 months | View on Amazon |
| Gardener’s Supply 1-Gallon Stoneware Pickling Crock | 9.6/10 | Stoneware | 1 gallon | Stoneware | Lidded bowl | Not stated | |
| Ohio Stoneware 5-Gallon Preserving Crock Cover | 9.4/10 | Stoneware | Cover only | Ceramic | Snap cover | No term | View on Amazon |
20 October 2026
What each one is
The three listings are not three crocks. The Gardener’s Supply listing is a complete 1-gallon lead-free stoneware pickling crock kit with a lidded bowl design. The Aosnttol listing is a 2.5-liter clear glass fermentation jar with a water seal lid. The Ohio Stoneware listing is a cover for a 5-gallon preserving crock: lead-free, natural stoneware that is oven, microwave and dishwasher safe, but a lid, not a vessel. Score them for what they are, not for what the comparison title assumes.
Capacity and size
The Gardener’s Supply states 1 gallon in a 15 by 14 by 13 in crock at 2 pounds. The Aosnttol states 2.5 liters, which its listing also gives as 0.66 gallon, in a 7 by 7 by 12 in jar at 3 pounds, suitable for families of 2 to 5 people. The Ohio Stoneware cover states 13.5 by 13.5 in to fit 5-gallon crocks, with a spec-table weight of 0.27 g that is not a usable figure for a stoneware lid. On stated capacity, the two vessels are small-batch size; the cover has no capacity of its own.
Lids and seals
The Aosnttol states a water seal lid: pour water around the bowl lid to create an airtight seal, and top up the water channel every week. The Gardener’s Supply states a lidded bowl design with a simple lid closure. The Ohio Stoneware states a snap closure cover. Only the glass listing states a water seal; the stoneware kit relies on its lid, and the cover is the lid for someone else’s crock.
Care and cleaning
The Gardener’s Supply listing contradicts itself on care: its bullets say hand wash only for best results and then call the crock dishwasher safe. When a listing gives both, hand washing is the safer read. The Aosnttol states washing the jar with water by hand and drying it fully. The Ohio Stoneware states oven, microwave and dishwasher safe, the most permissive care line here. All three state lead-free materials.
Which should you choose?
Choose the Aosnttol glass jar if you want to see the ferment, want the water seal, and like the stated 12-month warranty. Choose the Gardener’s Supply stoneware kit for traditional 1-gallon fermenting in an opaque crock. Choose the Ohio Stoneware cover only if you already own a 5-gallon crock that needs a lid; it is not a fermenting vessel on its own.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Top up the Aosnttol water channel every week, per its listing, to keep the seal.
- Hand wash the glass jar and dry it fully before storage, per its listing.
- The Ohio listing is a cover: confirm your crock is 5 gallons before buying it.
- All three listings state lead-free materials.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aosnttol Glass Fermentation Jar 2.5L | 9.6 | 29 | 20 | 20 | 7 | 4 |
| Gardener’s Supply 1-Gallon Stoneware Pickling Crock | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 20 | 7 | 0 |
| Ohio Stoneware 5-Gallon Preserving Crock Cover | 9.4 | 23 | 18 | 16 | 7 | 0 |
Point totals are rescaled to the 9.2 and 9.8 end points in a straight line, so two tools keep the same order they earned on points.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is the Ohio Stoneware listing a crock?
No. Its title and included components state it is a cover for a 5-gallon preserving crock, not the crock itself.
Which of these has a water seal?
The Aosnttol glass jar. Its listing states a water seal lid and weekly water top-ups.
Which is biggest?
The Ohio cover fits 5-gallon crocks, but it holds nothing itself. Of the two vessels, the Gardener’s Supply states 1 gallon against the Aosnttol at 2.5 liters.
Can I put these in the dishwasher?
The Ohio Stoneware states dishwasher safe. The Gardener’s Supply states both hand wash only and dishwasher safe; hand wash is the safer read. The Aosnttol states hand washing.
Do any state a warranty?
The Aosnttol states a 12-month warranty. The Ohio Stoneware states a warranty with no term. The Gardener’s Supply states no warranty.
More preserving guides
See fermentation crock vs jar, stoneware vs ceramic fermentation crock and German vs water seal fermentation crock.
More picks: fermentation weights for crocks and sauerkraut pounders for crocks.





