On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Midea 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Midea 3.5 Cu Ft Chest Freezer9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Chest Deep Freezer9.7/10View on Amazon - 4
FRIGIDAIRE EFRF3005-AMZ Chest Deep Freezer-Garage-ReadyView on Amazon - 5
Frigidaire Chest Deep FreezerView on Amazon - 6
Igloo 5.0 Cu Ft. Upright Deep Freezer Chest- Deep FreezerView on Amazon - 7
Small Chest Freezer 3.5 Cu.FtView on Amazon - 8
3.5 Cu.Ft Small Chest FreezerView on Amazon - 9
TABU 5.0 Cubic Feet Chest FreezerView on Amazon
The 3.5 vs 5 cu ft chest freezer question comes up when the harvest is in, the counters are full, and the freezer space runs short. The short answer: the 3.5 cu ft size suits a smaller harvest and a tight corner, while the 5.0 cu ft size holds more of a season. This guide lines up the listings compared here, the 3.5 cu ft listings and the 5.0 cu ft listing, so you can match the size to the harvest you put up.
Runners-up to consider
FRIGIDAIRE EFRF3005-AMZ Chest Deep Freezer-Garage-ReadyCheck price on Amazon
Frigidaire Chest Deep FreezerCheck price on Amazon
Igloo 5.0 Cu Ft. Upright Deep Freezer Chest- Deep FreezerCheck price on Amazon
Small Chest Freezer 3.5 Cu.FtCheck price on Amazon
3.5 Cu.Ft Small Chest FreezerCheck price on Amazon
TABU 5.0 Cubic Feet Chest FreezerCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
3.5 vs 5 Cu Ft Chest Freezer: The Short List
Each listing below states its size, its temperature settings and whether it includes a basket or a drain, in the order this guide ranks them.
| Freezer | Capacity stated | Temperature settings | Basket and drain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire EFRF3005-AMZ | 3.5 cu ft | 7 settings | Removable basket, defrost drain |
| TABU 5.0 Cu Ft | 5.0 cu ft | 7-level dial | Removable basket, drain: Not stated |
| Climate Choice 3.5 Cu Ft | 3.5 cu ft | 7 settings | Removable basket, drain: Not stated |
| BODACIOUS 3.5 Cu Ft | 3.5 cu ft | 6 settings | Removable basket, frost drainage port |
Start with the size, not the brand
The size question comes before the brand question, because the size sets how much of a harvest the freezer holds and how much floor it takes. The listings compared here state 3.5 cu ft for the Frigidaire, BODACIOUS and Climate Choice freezers, and 5.0 cu ft for the TABU freezer. The 5.0 cu ft listing states a footprint of 21.06 x 20.27 x 29.13 inches, while the 3.5 cu ft listings state 23.0 x 23.0 x 35.0 inches for the Frigidaire, 20.47 x 16.73 x 28.54 inches for the BODACIOUS and 18.5 x 22.4 x 29.3 inches for the Climate Choice. Measure the spot, including the height the lid needs to open, before you order.
Capacity is not the same as footprint: the TABU listing states the larger capacity in a footprint close to the 3.5 cu ft listings. The chest freezer sizes guide lines up capacity and dimensions across more listings.
The 3.5 cu ft freezers
The Frigidaire listing states a garage-ready chest freezer with 7 temperature settings, a removable vinyl coated wire basket, an easy access exterior defrosting drain, a power-on indicator light and two levelling legs, with a 1-year warranty and a weight of 35.0 pounds. The Climate Choice listing states 7 temperature settings from -11.4°F to 10.2°F, a noise level below 40dB, energy use of 0.37kWh/24h, two built-in wheels, a removable storage basket and a 1-year warranty, with a weight of 47.53 pounds. The BODACIOUS listing states 6 temperature settings, a frost drainage port, a removable basket and a 15-month warranty, with dimensions of 20.47 x 16.73 x 28.54 inches and a weight of 38.75 pounds.
Listings at the same size still differ in the details. The Frigidaire is the only 3.5 cu ft listing that states garage-ready and a defrost drain with a power-on light, the Climate Choice is the only 3.5 cu ft listing that states wheels and a noise figure, and the BODACIOUS is the only 3.5 cu ft listing that states a 15-month warranty. Check the listing for the feature you care about.
The 5.0 cu ft freezer
The TABU listing states 5.0 cu ft of storage in a footprint of 21.06 x 20.27 x 29.13 inches, with a 7-level adjustable dial from -7.6°F to 6.8°F, a hinged door that opens from 45° to 90°, a noise level at or below 40dB and a high-efficiency R600a compressor. It also states a removable storage basket and adjustable leveling legs, and the listing states no warranty term. The larger size is the reason to pick it, with more room for a season of seafood, ice cream and meat, the foods the listing names.
Temperature settings and defrost
Temperature control is where the listings differ most. The Frigidaire and Climate Choice listings state 7 temperature settings, the TABU listing states a 7-level dial, and the BODACIOUS listing states 6 settings. The Climate Choice listing states a range from -11.4°F to 10.2°F, and the TABU listing states a range from -7.6°F to 6.8°F. The Frigidaire and BODACIOUS listings state no temperature range, only the count of settings.
Defrost is manual on the BODACIOUS and TABU listings, and the Frigidaire and BODACIOUS listings state a drain for it: an easy access exterior defrosting drain on the Frigidaire, and a frost drainage port on the BODACIOUS. The Climate Choice and TABU listings state no drain. The how cold does a chest freezer get guide compares the temperatures freezers state.
What to measure before you buy
Check the listing dimensions against the spot before you order:
- Footprint: the listings state 23.0 x 23.0 inches for the Frigidaire, 20.47 x 16.73 inches for the BODACIOUS, 18.5 x 22.4 inches for the Climate Choice and 21.06 x 20.27 inches for the TABU.
- Height: the listings state 35.0 inches for the Frigidaire, 28.54 inches for the BODACIOUS, 29.3 inches for the Climate Choice and 29.13 inches for the TABU.
- Door swing: the TABU listing states a hinged door that opens from 45° to 90°, so leave room above and in front of the lid.
- Drain access: the Frigidaire and BODACIOUS listings state a drain, so leave room to reach it when the freezer needs defrosting.
- Weight: the listings state 35.0 pounds for the Frigidaire, 38.75 pounds for the BODACIOUS and 47.53 pounds for the Climate Choice, and the TABU listing states no weight.
Garage placement is a separate check. The Frigidaire listing states garage-ready, and the BODACIOUS and TABU listings name garages among the places they suit. The chest freezer vs garage refrigerator comparison walks through garage placement in more detail.
What this guide does not cover
This is a size and listing guide. It does not give recipes, processing times, pressures, headspace figures or altitude changes. Take those from current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation guidance, and follow them exactly for each food. Every food storage guide on the site is collected in the food storage section.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is a 3.5 cu ft chest freezer big enough for a garden harvest?
It depends on the harvest. The 3.5 cu ft listings state removable baskets and 7 temperature settings on the Frigidaire and Climate Choice listings, so a smaller harvest fits with room to organize. If the harvest fills the freezer, the 5.0 cu ft TABU listing states more room in a footprint close to the 3.5 cu ft listings.
What is the difference between a 3.5 and a 5.0 cu ft chest freezer?
Capacity and the listing that states it. The TABU listing states 5.0 cu ft with a 7-level dial and a hinged door that opens from 45° to 90°, while the 3.5 cu ft listings state the same 7 temperature settings on the Frigidaire and Climate Choice listings and 6 settings on the BODACIOUS listing. The footprint figures are close: 21.06 x 20.27 x 29.13 inches for the TABU against 23.0 x 23.0 x 35.0 inches for the Frigidaire.
Do chest freezers need a drain?
A drain makes manual defrost easier. The Frigidaire listing states an easy access exterior defrosting drain, and the BODACIOUS listing states a frost drainage port. The Climate Choice and TABU listings state no drain, so check the listing before you buy if a drain matters to you.
Can a chest freezer go in the garage?
The Frigidaire listing states garage-ready. The BODACIOUS and TABU listings name garages among the places they suit, and the Climate Choice listing names apartments, offices and garages. Check the temperature range the listing states against the garage, since the listings state different ranges.
More preserving guides
See every produce storage guide and all storage guides.
More picks: chest freezer uses, chest freezer sizes, root cellar vs chest freezer and mini freezer size.





