On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
NESCO FD-1040 Gardenmaster9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Excalibur Select 5-Tray9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Silicone Dehydrator Sheets9.4/10View on Amazon
When the garden gives more than the counter can hold, excalibur 9 tray vs nesco gardenmaster is the comparison that decides how the extra harvest gets dried. One side is the Excalibur tray stack with horizontal airflow, and the other is the NESCO Gardenmaster with round trays and digital controls. We compared the listings side by side, looking strictly at what each Amazon listing publishes.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: pick the Excalibur side for a 5-tray stack with horizontal airflow, an 85°F to 165°F range, an 80-hour timer and 3 square feet of drying space. Pick the NESCO Gardenmaster for 1000 watts, 4 trays that expand to 20, a 48-hour timer and a 90F to 160F range. The silicone sheets belong with the Excalibur side only, since they fit 14 by 14 inch square trays and not the NESCO 15.5-inch round trays. Note the mismatch up front: the Excalibur listing here is a 5-tray model, not a 9-tray model.
The 3 picks
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | NESCO FD-1040 Gardenmaster | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Excalibur Select 5-Tray | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Silicone Dehydrator Sheets | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |

NESCO FD-1040 Gardenmaster
A 1000-watt digital dehydrator with 4 trays expandable to 20, a timer up to 48 hours and a temperature range of 90F to 160F.
Pros
- 4 trays expand to 20 BPA-free trays, so capacity grows with the harvest
- 1000 watts with Converga-Flow airflow for even drying without tray rotation
- Digital timer up to 48 hours and a 90F to 160F temperature range
- Top-mounted fan keeps liquid drips out of the heating element
Cons
- 4 trays in the box is a small start for a large harvest until expansion trays are added
- Round 15.5-inch trays do not take the square 14 by 14 inch liners in this comparison
- The listing does not state the drying space in square feet
- The listing gives no drying space figure, so the Excalibur 3 square feet figure has no match on this side

Excalibur Select 5-Tray
A 5-tray dehydrator with Parallexx horizontal airflow, an 85°F to 165°F range, an 80-hour timer and 3 square feet of drying space.
Pros
- Parallexx horizontal airflow dries every tray evenly without rotation
- 85°F to 165°F range covers herbs and flowers through fruit, vegetables and jerky
- LED touch screen and an 80 hour timer make time and temperature simple to set
- Chrome trays with a mesh screen, crumb tray and drop down door for loading and cleanup
Cons
- The listing is a 5-tray model, not the 9-tray model in the focus keyword
- No wattage is stated, so power cannot be compared with the NESCO 1000 watts
- The listing does not state whether the trays expand beyond 5

Silicone Dehydrator Sheets
A 6-piece set of reusable food grade silicone liners sized 13.5 by 13.5 inches for 14 by 14 inch dehydrator trays.
Pros
- 6 reusable liners sized 13.5 by 13.5 inches for 14 by 14 inch trays
- Food grade silicone, BPA free, safe and non-toxic, with a non-stick surface
- Raised lip edge keeps liquid and moisture in and the kitchen neat
- Suits fruit rolls, vegetable rolls, jerky, fruit, meat, herbs and crackers
Cons
- A tray liner, not a dehydrator, so it dries nothing on its own
- Cannot be used alone; the listing states it must sit on a hard tray
- Fits 14 by 14 inch square trays only, so it does not fit the NESCO 15.5-inch round trays
- The listing states the silicone withstands low and high temperatures but gives no temperature figures
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Excalibur 14" x 14" Polyscreen Mesh Tray Screen Inserts for 5Check price on Amazon
SFV 6 Pack Silicone Dehydrator TraysCheck price on Amazon
Excalibur 9 Tray vs Nesco Gardenmaster: Side by Side
| Dehydrator | Harvest Score | Trays | Temperature Range | Timer | Power | Warranty | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NESCO FD-1040 Gardenmaster | 9.7/10 | 4, expandable to 20 | 90F to 160F | Up to 48 hours | 1000 watts | 1 Year limited warranty | View on Amazon |
| Excalibur Select 5-Tray | 9.6/10 | 5 | 85°F to 165°F | 80 hour timer | Not stated | 1-Year Limited Warranty | View on Amazon |
| Silicone Dehydrator Sheets | 9.4/10 | Fits 14 inch trays | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | View on Amazon |
Each spec is the brand’s own rating, read off the product listing on 5 November 2026.
What each side dries
Both sides dry the same harvest: fruit, vegetables, herbs and jerky. The Excalibur listing names jerky, fruit, vegetables, herbs and pet treats, with a range from herbs and flowers up to jerky. The NESCO listing names fruits, vegetables, herbs and jerky, and adds garden harvests, hunting trips and bulk grocery shopping. The silicone sheets list fruit rolls, vegetable rolls, jerky, fruit, meat, herbs and crackers.
The split is in how the air moves. The Excalibur uses Parallexx horizontal airflow, which circulates warm air across every tray for even drying without rotation. The NESCO uses Converga-Flow airflow with a top-mounted fan, which the listing says gives even drying without tray rotation and keeps drips out of the heating element. Neither listing states a wattage for the Excalibur side, so the NESCO 1000 watts has no match there, and the comparison cannot call either side stronger on power.
Trays and capacity
Tray count is where the two sides part ways. The NESCO starts with 4 trays and expands to 20 BPA-free trays, so capacity grows with the harvest. The Excalibur listing states 5 trays and 3 square feet of drying space, with no expansion. The silicone sheets add no trays; they line trays already owned.
Shape matters as much as count. The NESCO trays are 15.5-inch diameter rounds, sized for whole fruits and full jerky batches. The silicone sheets are 13.5 by 13.5 inch squares made for 14 by 14 inch metal trays, and the listing names Excalibur dehydrators as the fit. A square liner does not sit on a round tray, so the sheets serve the Excalibur side and not the Gardenmaster side. The best dehydrator sheets guide covers liners, and the round vs rectangular food dehydrator guide compares the two tray shapes.
Temperature, timer and controls
Both dehydrators list a digital control and a wide range. The Excalibur runs from 85°F to 165°F with an LED touch screen and an 80 hour timer. The NESCO runs from 90F to 160F with a digital timer programmable up to 48 hours. The Excalibur timer runs longer on paper, and the NESCO range starts higher, but neither listing states how long a batch takes.
Controls differ in the details. The Excalibur has a drop down door, chrome trays, a mesh screen and a crumb tray, which the listing says simplify loading and cleanup. The NESCO includes a fruit roll sheet, a clean-a-screen, jerky seasoning and a recipe guide in the box. The NESCO fan sits on top to keep drips out of the heating element, while the Excalibur airflow runs horizontally across the trays. Neither listing states a noise figure or a cord length.
Listing gaps to check
Read the Excalibur listing with care: the comparison is filed under the Excalibur 9 tray side, but the listing is the Select Series 5-tray model, and the title and the spec table agree on 5 trays and model DH05SCBK13. A dryer who wants 9 trays will not find them here, and no expansion beyond 5 trays is stated.
The silicone sheets need the same care: they are a liner, not a dehydrator, and the listing states the soft silicone cannot be used alone and must sit on a hard tray. The listing also states the silicone withstands low and high temperatures but gives no figures, so no heat limit can be quoted for them. The NESCO listing states the widest set of figures of the 3: power, tray count, expansion, timer, temperature range, tray size and warranty, with the drying space unstated.
Which should you choose?
Choose the Excalibur side if you want a 5-tray stack with horizontal airflow, a temperature range of 85°F to 165°F and an 80-hour timer, for herbs, fruit, vegetables and jerky in batches that fit 3 square feet. Add the silicone sheets if your trays are 14 by 14 inch squares and you dry fruit rolls or crackers. Compare tray shapes in the horizontal-flow vs vertical-flow dehydrator guide.
Choose the NESCO Gardenmaster if you want to start with 4 trays and expand to 20, with 1000 watts, a digital timer up to 48 hours and a 90F to 160F range. The 15.5-inch round trays suit whole fruit and full jerky batches, and the top-mounted fan keeps drips out. Start with the best food dehydrator guide to size your dryer.
Whichever side you pick, check the tray shape before buying liners or extra trays; the best dehydrator for jerky guide covers jerky batches.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Sort the harvest into fruit, vegetables, herbs and jerky before loading, so each tray holds one kind.
- Load the Excalibur chrome trays with the mesh screen in place, and keep the crumb tray with the unit.
- Keep the silicone liners on a hard tray, since the listing states the soft silicone cannot be used alone.
- Keep the NESCO fruit roll sheet and clean-a-screen with the unit for the next batch.
- Check the NESCO top-mounted fan area and the Excalibur drop down door for drips after each batch.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NESCO FD-1040 Gardenmaster | 9.7 | 30 | 21 | 21 | 8 | 4 |
| Excalibur Select 5-Tray | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 5 | 4 |
| Silicone Dehydrator Sheets | 9.4 | 23 | 20 | 19 | 7 | 0 |
We convert every point total into a number no lower than 9.2 and no higher than 9.8, keeping the order the points set.
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For dehydrators, safety covers the stated features: BPA-free trays and a top-mounted fan on the NESCO, horizontal airflow on the Excalibur, and BPA-free food grade silicone on the sheets. The NESCO leads on performance and value for its 1000 watts and expansion to 20 trays, while the Excalibur leads on timer length with its 80 hour timer. Two of the 3 listings state a warranty term, and the sheets state none. How we pick explains the weights.
FAQ: preserving at home
How many trays does the NESCO FD-1040 come with?
4 trays, expandable to 20 BPA-free trays, 15.5 inches in diameter.
What temperature range does the Excalibur Select Series list?
85°F to 165°F, set on an LED touch screen with an 80 hour timer.
Do the silicone sheets fit the NESCO Gardenmaster trays?
No. The sheets measure 13.5 by 13.5 inches and fit 14 by 14 inch square metal trays, while the NESCO trays are 15.5-inch diameter rounds.
How long a timer does each dehydrator list?
The Excalibur lists an 80 hour timer, and the NESCO lists a digital timer up to 48 hours.
Do any of the 3 listings state a warranty?
Two of them do: the NESCO states a 1 Year limited warranty, and the Excalibur states a 1-Year Limited Warranty. The sheets state no warranty term.
More preserving guides
See every food dehydrators guide and all food drying guides.
More picks: food dehydrators, dehydrators for jerky, dehydrators for fruit and dehydrator sheets.





