On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
FENRIR 204 Regular Mouth9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
laffeya Stainless Steel 4-Set9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Fermentaholics Gallon Lid9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
SLifeJars 240 Regular Mouth9.6/10View on Amazon
A counter full of jars at harvest time forces a small choice before anything gets put up: fermentation lids vs canning lids. A fermentation lid lets gas escape while a ferment bubbles away, and a canning lid seals a jar shut for the canner. This comparison weighs fit, seals, materials and pack size, using only what each maker states.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose fermentation lids for sauerkraut, pickles, kimchi, hot sauce or a home brew that needs to vent gas; the laffeya set covers wide-mouth jars, and the Fermentaholics lid fits gallon jars. Choose canning lids for water bath or pressure canning, where a fresh seal matters; the FENRIR pack and the SLifeJars set both cover regular mouth jars at 70 mm. Neither side replaces the other.
Four examples
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FENRIR 204 Regular Mouth | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | laffeya Stainless Steel 4-Set | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Fermentaholics Gallon Lid | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | SLifeJars 240 Regular Mouth | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |

FENRIR 204 Regular Mouth
A 204 pack of 70 mm split-type metal canning lids with a food-grade silicone seal ring, made for regular mouth mason jars.
Pros
- 204 lids in one pack, sized 70 mm for regular mouth mason jars
- Food-grade silicone seal ring for an airtight seal
- BPA-free coating on tinplate metal, stated as corrosion-resistant
- Maker states the lids fit Ball and Kerr regular mouth jars
Cons
- Regular mouth only at 70 mm; wide-mouth jars need a different lid
- No rings are included; the pack is lids only
- A 204 count suits large batches, not a small-batch canner
- No warranty term is stated

laffeya Stainless Steel 4-Set
A set of 4 stainless steel fermentation lids with airlocks, silicone rings and grommets for 3.38 inch wide-mouth mason jars.
Pros
- 4 stainless steel lids with 4 airlocks, 5 silicone rings and 10 grommets
- Fits 3.38 inch wide-mouth jars, including Ball pint and quart sizes
- All parts are removable and the lids are dishwasher safe
- Silicone ring under each lid seals the lid to the jar
Cons
- Jars are not included, so the set needs wide-mouth jars on hand
- Maker warns against putting the plastic airlocks in boiling water
- Wide mouth only; regular mouth jars need a different lid
- No warranty term is stated

Fermentaholics Gallon Lid
A one-gallon fermentation lid with a gasket, grommet and S-airlock that turns a gallon jar into a fermenter.
Pros
- Turns a gallon jar into a fermenter with lid, gasket, grommet and airlock
- Fits gallon jars with a 110 mm (4.375 inch) outer diameter
- Food-grade materials, dishwasher safe
- Silicone gasket and rubber grommet hold the airlock in place
Cons
- One lid only, so each gallon jar needs its own
- Sized for gallon jars at 110 mm, so it does not suit smaller jars
- White plastic lid, not stainless steel
- No warranty term is stated

SLifeJars 240 Regular Mouth
A 240 piece set of 70 mm regular mouth canning lids and rings with silicone seals, made for water bath and pressure canning.
Pros
- 240 pieces: 120 lids and 120 rings in one set
- Split-type design, so lids and rings clean separately
- Food-grade tinplate with a silicone sealing ring, stated as airtight and leakproof
- Lids are reusable for dry storage such as spices and seeds
Cons
- Lids are one-time use for water bath or pressure canning
- Regular mouth only at 70 mm; the maker states the set is not suitable for wide-mouth jars
- Rings must be tightened to fingertip tightness only, or lids can swell and deform
- No warranty term is stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Regular Mouth Mason Jar Canning Lids 16 Dozen or 192 LidsCheck price on Amazon
Fermentaholics Silicone Fermentation Stretch LidsCheck price on Amazon
Fermentation LidsCheck price on Amazon
316 Stainless Steel Fermentation Lids 3 Silicone WaterlessCheck price on Amazon
2 PCS Glass Fermentation WeightsCheck price on Amazon
Ball Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsCheck price on Amazon
Fermentation lids vs canning lids: side by side
| Lid | Harvest Score | Lid Type | Jar Fit | Pack Count | Material | Seal | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FENRIR 204 Regular Mouth | 9.6/10 | Canning lid | 70 mm regular mouth | 204 lids | Tinplate metal, BPA-free coating | Food-grade silicone seal ring | View on Amazon |
| laffeya Stainless Steel 4-Set | 9.6/10 | Fermentation lid | 3.38 inch wide mouth | 4 lids, 4 airlocks | Stainless steel | Silicone ring, airlock | View on Amazon |
| Fermentaholics Gallon Lid | 9.6/10 | Fermentation lid | 110 mm gallon jars | 1 lid with airlock | Plastic, silicone, rubber | Silicone gasket, S-airlock | View on Amazon |
| SLifeJars 240 Regular Mouth | 9.6/10 | Canning lid | 70 mm regular mouth | 240 pieces | Tinplate, silicone | Silicone sealing ring | View on Amazon |
Each spec is the brand’s own rating, read off the product listing on 19 October 2026.
What each lid is for
A fermentation lid is a venting lid. Both fermentation examples here pair a lid with an airlock: the Fermentaholics lid carries an S-airlock on a gallon jar, and the laffeya set pairs each stainless steel lid with its own airlock. Gas leaves through the airlock while the gasket or ring keeps the seal airtight, which suits sauerkraut, pickles, kimchi, hot sauce and home brews.
A canning lid is a sealing lid. Both canning examples are split-type metal lids with a silicone seal for regular mouth mason jars at 70 mm: the FENRIR pack holds 204 lids, and the SLifeJars set holds 120 lids and 120 rings. SLifeJars states the lids are one-time use for water bath or pressure canning, and reusable for dry storage. Neither canning listing includes an airlock.
Jar fit and pack size
Fit decides the buy, because the two sides fit different jars. The Fermentaholics lid fits gallon jars with a 110 mm (4.375 inch) outer diameter. The laffeya lids fit wide-mouth mason jars with a 3.38 inch (8.6 cm) mouth. Both canning sets fit regular mouth mason jars at 70 mm; FENRIR states the lids fit Ball and Kerr regular mouth jars.
Pack size runs the other way: 204 lids in the FENRIR pack and 240 pieces in the SLifeJars set, against 4 lids in the laffeya set and a single lid from Fermentaholics. Bulk counts suit a canner who fills jar after jar, while the smaller sets suit a fermenter who runs a few jars at a time. Jars are not included with the laffeya set.
Lids, seals and airlocks
The seal is where the two sides part ways. A fermentation lid seals against the jar while its airlock lets gas out: the Fermentaholics lid uses a silicone gasket with a black rubber grommet that holds the S-airlock, and each laffeya lid has a silicone ring underneath plus a silicone grommet. A canning lid seals and stays sealed: the FENRIR lids carry a food-grade silicone seal ring, and the SLifeJars lids carry a sealing ring around the edge.
Both canning listings describe their seals as airtight, and SLifeJars adds leakproof.
Materials and cleaning
Materials split along the same line. The laffeya lids are stainless steel with silicone rings and grommets; all parts are removable and the lids are dishwasher safe. The Fermentaholics lid is white plastic with a silicone gasket and a rubber grommet, and the maker states all four parts are food-grade and dishwasher safe. The canning lids are tinplate metal: FENRIR adds a BPA-free coating and describes the lids as corrosion-resistant, while SLifeJars describes thicker materials that resist deforming.
The laffeya maker warns against putting the plastic airlocks in boiling water. The SLifeJars maker states rings should be screwed down to fingertip tightness only, because overtightening can swell and deform the lids.
Listing gaps to check
A few counts differ, so check before ordering. The SLifeJars set is sold as 240 pieces, 120 lids and 120 rings, but the maker also gives a quantity of 180. The laffeya set is sold as 4 lids with 4 airlocks, but the maker also gives a count of 2 pieces and a count of 1. No listing here states a warranty term, and the FENRIR pack includes lids only, with rings bought separately.
How the scores work
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FENRIR 204 Regular Mouth | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 21 | 8 | 0 |
| laffeya Stainless Steel 4-Set | 9.6 | 30 | 22 | 21 | 7 | 0 |
| Fermentaholics Gallon Lid | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| SLifeJars 240 Regular Mouth | 9.6 | 29 | 20 | 22 | 7 | 0 |
We convert every point total into a number no lower than 9.2 and no higher than 9.8, keeping the order the points set.
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty; for lids, safety covers the stated features that control air and sealing. No listing states a warranty term, so no product earns warranty points. How we pick explains the weights.
How to choose the best fermentation lids vs canning lids
Match the lid to the jar
Start with the jar mouth, because no lid here fits every jar. Gallon jars take the Fermentaholics lid at 110 mm, wide-mouth mason jars take the laffeya lids at 3.38 inches, and regular mouth mason jars take either canning set at 70 mm. Measure the jar mouth before ordering. New fermenters can compare starter sets in the best fermentation lids for beginners guide.
Match the lid to the job
Then match the lid to the job. Ferments that bubble need an airlock; the how to use an airlock for fermentation guide walks through the part. Jars for the canner need a fresh sealing lid each time, so pick a set with enough pieces for the batch.
Buy the count the batch needs
Finally, buy the count the batch needs. A 204 lid pack or a 240 piece set suits a canner who fills jar after jar, while a 4 lid set suits a fermenter who runs a few jars at a time. The SLifeJars set is the only listing here that bundles rings with lids.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Match each lid to its jar mouth before buying.
- Both fermentation lids are dishwasher safe, and the laffeya airlocks stay out of boiling water.
- Tighten SLifeJars rings to fingertip tightness only.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can you use fermentation lids for canning?
No. A fermentation lid vents gas through an airlock, while canning needs a sealing lid. Use the lid type that matches the job.
Can you reuse canning lids?
The SLifeJars maker states the lids are one-time use for water bath or pressure canning, and reusable for dry storage. The FENRIR listing does not state reuse.
What size jars do these lids fit?
The Fermentaholics lid fits gallon jars at 110 mm, the laffeya lids fit wide-mouth mason jars at 3.38 inches, and both canning sets fit regular mouth mason jars at 70 mm.
Do fermentation lids need an airlock?
Both fermentation listings here include one: the Fermentaholics lid carries an S-airlock, and the laffeya set includes 4 airlocks.
Are these lids dishwasher safe?
The Fermentaholics lid and the laffeya lids are stated as dishwasher safe. Neither canning listing states dishwasher safety.
More preserving guides
See every fermentation kits guide, every canning lids guide and all canning guides.
More picks: fermentation lids for beginners, canning lids for jelly, Ball vs Kerr canning lids and can you reuse canning lids.





