On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Mrs. Wages Pickling Lime9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
McCormick Pickling Spice9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Home Fermenting Guide9.5/10View on Amazon
The fermenting vs pickling choice is decided by what you want the microbes to do: fermenting lets live cultures transform the food, while pickling preserves it in an acid brine or with pickling ingredients. We compared four listings that show the difference clearly, two fermenting guides and two pickling ingredients, looking strictly at what each listing publishes.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose fermenting if you want live-cultured foods and drinks, from kimchi to kombucha; the Farmhouse Culture guide packs 100 recipes into a 2.94 pound volume, and the Home Fermenting guide offers a 9-step small-batch method. Choose pickling if you want crisp pickles fast; the Mrs. Wages pickling lime is food-grade calcium hydroxide in a 1 lb resealable bag, and the McCormick pickling spice blends 11 spices, seeds and herbs in a 12 oz container. Neither side’s listings state that the results are shelf stable, so follow current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation guidance for storage.
The examples
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Farmhouse Culture Guide | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Mrs. Wages Pickling Lime | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | McCormick Pickling Spice | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | Home Fermenting Guide | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Farmhouse Culture Guide
A guide to fermenting with 100 live-cultured food and drink recipes, from kimchi to kombucha.
Pros
- 100 recipes stated
- Covers kimchi to kombucha
- Live-cultured focus
- Ten Speed Press edition
Cons
- 2.94 lb, heavy for a guide
- 2019 edition
- 100 recipes can overwhelm beginners
- No safety certification stated
Pros
- Food-grade calcium hydroxide stated
- No additives or preservatives
- Kosher certified
- Resealable 1 lb bag
Cons
- Pickling use only, not fermenting
- 1 lb bag, single purpose
- No safety certification stated
- No warranty term stated
Pros
- 11 spices, seeds and herbs
- Classic tangy pickle flavor stated
- Kosher
- Made for culinary professionals
Cons
- Flavor only, no crispness agent
- 12 oz, single container
- No safety certification stated
- No warranty term stated
Pros
- 9-step small-batch method
- Safety-focused approach stated
- Small-batch focus
- Newest edition here, 2026
Cons
- 12.2 oz, thin volume
- 2026 edition, newest and least proven
- Independently published
- No safety certification stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Masontops Pickle Pebble Glass Infinity Weights for FermentingCheck price on Amazon
Vencer Traditional Glass Fermenting Jar 5 Liter With LidCheck price on Amazon
Ohio Stoneware High Bristol Pickling and Fermenting Crock 2Check price on Amazon
Fermentation Crock 3.8Liter/1 Gallon Stoneware Pot forCheck price on Amazon
Vencer Wide Mouth Jar Split Fermentation WeightCheck price on Amazon
Fermenting vs pickling: side by side
| Product | Harvest Score | Side | Type | Size | Key feature | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmhouse Culture Guide | 9.6/10 | Fermenting | Book | 2.94 lb | 100 recipes, kimchi to kombucha | View on Amazon |
| Mrs. Wages Pickling Lime | 9.6/10 | Pickling | Pickling lime | 1 lb | Food-grade calcium hydroxide | View on Amazon |
| McCormick Pickling Spice | 9.6/10 | Pickling | Spice blend | 12 oz | 11 spices, seeds and herbs | View on Amazon |
| Home Fermenting Guide | 9.5/10 | Fermenting | Book | 12.2 oz | 9-step small-batch method | View on Amazon |
Specs below are what each maker states on its listing (gathered 20 October 2026).
What each side actually is
Fermenting, in these listings, means live cultures doing the work: the Farmhouse Culture guide covers live-cultured foods and drinks with 100 recipes from kimchi to kombucha, and the Home Fermenting guide promises a 9-step method for small-batch ferments. Pickling, in these listings, means ingredients that make pickles: the Mrs. Wages pickling lime is food-grade calcium hydroxide for extra crisp cucumbers, green tomato pickles, watermelon rinds and citron pickles, and the McCormick pickling spice is a blend of 11 spices, seeds and herbs for the classic tangy pickle flavor. For the jar side of the craft, see our glass vs plastic fermentation jar comparison.
One side is knowledge and the other is ingredients, so the comparison is about approach, not a head-to-head product match. The two books teach; the lime and the spice go into the jar. If you want the deeper dive on the difference, our fermented vs vinegar pickles guide compares the two methods directly.
What the listings state and what they do not
The fermenting guides state their scope clearly: 100 recipes in the Farmhouse Culture volume, a 9-step small-batch method in the Home Fermenting guide. The pickling ingredients state theirs: food-grade calcium hydroxide with no additives or preservatives and kosher certification for the lime, 11 spices with kosher status for the McCormick blend. None of the four listings states a processing time, a salt ratio or a storage time, and per our policy we do not repeat what is not there. None claims the results are shelf stable, so check current USDA guidance before storing anything at room temperature.
Which should you choose?
Choose fermenting if you want live-cultured foods and drinks and are willing to learn the method; the Farmhouse Culture guide’s 100 recipes cover kimchi to kombucha, and the Home Fermenting guide keeps batches small. Start with the fermentation kits section for the gear.
Choose pickling if you want crisp pickles from cucumbers, green tomatoes or watermelon rinds; the pickling lime adds crispness and the pickling spice adds the classic flavor. Our best pickle jar for refrigerator pickles picks cover the right vessels.
Many preservers do both, because live cultures and pickling ingredients serve different cravings and different harvests.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Follow current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation guidance for processing and storage; none of these listings states either.
- Keep ferments and pickles refrigerated unless a reliable recipe says otherwise.
- Reseal the pickling lime bag after use; it is a 1 lb pouch, not a shaker.
- Measure the pickling spice rather than eyeballing it; the 12 oz container is a blend, not a single spice.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmhouse Culture Guide | 9.6 | 30 | 20 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| Mrs. Wages Pickling Lime | 9.6 | 28 | 20 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| McCormick Pickling Spice | 9.6 | 28 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| Home Fermenting Guide | 9.5 | 29 | 18 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
Point totals are rescaled to the 9.2 and 9.8 end points in a straight line, so two tools keep the same order they earned on points. When neither power nor a listed safety feature is involved, safety is skipped and the score is calculated over 90 points.
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty, as explained on our How we pick page. For books and ingredients, performance reflects the stated scope: the Farmhouse Culture guide scores highest for its 100 recipes, the pickling lime for its food-grade calcium hydroxide and kosher certification. None of the four states a safety certification or a warranty term, so those scores are zero across the board.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is fermenting the same as pickling?
No. In these listings, fermenting means live-cultured foods and drinks made with microbial cultures, while pickling means preserving with ingredients like pickling lime and pickling spice.
Which book has more recipes?
The Farmhouse Culture Guide to Fermenting states 100 recipes, from kimchi to kombucha. The Home Fermenting guide states a 9-step method rather than a recipe count.
What is pickling lime?
The Mrs. Wages listing states it is food-grade calcium hydroxide with no additives or preservatives, kosher certified, used for extra crisp pickles.
Do any of these state a warranty?
No. None of the four listings states a warranty term.
More preserving guides
See every fermentation kit guide and all storage guides.
More picks: fermented vs vinegar pickles, glass vs plastic fermentation jar and pickle jar for refrigerator pickles.









