Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Glass Carboy vs Plastic Carboy: Which One Should You Buy?
Storage

Glass Carboy vs Plastic Carboy: Which One Should You Buy?

Glass carboy vs plastic carboy comes down to the listings: glass carboys are reusable, easy to clean and seal airtight, with 3 and 5 gallon sizes.

On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1M MCIRCO 24-Piece Glass Food Storage Containers with LidsM MCIRCO 24-Piece Glass Food Storage Containers with Lids9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2C CREST 10-Pack Glass Meal Prep Containers with LidsC CREST 10-Pack Glass Meal Prep Containers with Lids9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3JSCARES 40-Piece Plastic Food Storage Containers with LidsJSCARES 40-Piece Plastic Food Storage Containers with Lids9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 43 Gallon Clear Glass Italian Carboy3 Gallon Clear Glass Italian CarboyView on Amazon
  5. 5Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy SetSuzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy SetView on Amazon
  6. 6Suzile 3 Gallon Glass Carboy Set with StoppersSuzile 3 Gallon Glass Carboy Set with StoppersView on Amazon
  7. 7North Mountain Supply Glass Carboy Fermenting JugNorth Mountain Supply Glass Carboy Fermenting JugView on Amazon
  8. 83 Gallon Glass Carboy3 Gallon Glass CarboyView on Amazon
  9. 95 Gallon Plastic Dispenser Carboy with Spigot5 Gallon Plastic Dispenser Carboy with SpigotView on Amazon

A batch of wine or beer ready for its fermenter is the moment the carboy question comes up. Glass carboy vs plastic carboy: which one should you buy? The listings point to glass as the reusable, easy-to-clean choice that seals airtight, while plastic is named only as the fermenter glass replaces. The 4 glass carboys below show the sizes, kits and limits to compare.

Runners-up to consider

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Glass carboy vs plastic carboy: the short list

The 4 carboys here are all glass, in 3 gallon and 5 gallon sizes, with stoppers and airlocks in the kits and a #7 stopper fit on the FastRack carboys. The table lines them up from the fullest kit to the simplest jug.

Carboy Size What comes with it Note
Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy Set 5 gallon Drilled and undrilled stoppers, bubble airlock, handle, brush Soda-lime glass, 40 degrees Celsius max
Ziliny 2 Pieces 3 Gallon Glass Carboy 3 gallon, 2 pieces Drilled and undrilled stoppers, airlocks Soda-lime glass, 40 degrees Celsius max
FastRack Italian Carboy 5 Gallon 5 gallon Opening fits a #7 stopper, sold separately Wide mouth, reusable
FastRack 3 Gallon Clear Glass Italian Carboy 3 gallon Opening fits a #7 stopper, stopper not included Non-slip base, 8.2 lbs empty

What glass does better, from the listings

Glass is the reusable choice in every listing here. The FastRack listings call their carboys a reusable alternative to plastic fermenters, built for repeated use. The wide mouth makes it easy to clean and transfer ingredients, and the glass seals airtight to protect the brew. The Suzile and Ziliny listings add that transparent glass is durable and resistant to scratches and wear, and that the clear glass is a decoration in the kitchen or dining room as well.

The uses the listings state are wide. The FastRack carboys state beer brewing, wine fermentation and kombucha, while the Suzile and Ziliny listings add cider and mead, and state that the carboys suit home kitchens and restaurants. The Suzile listing states no stringing of flavors, and the Ziliny listing states the carboy will not cause odor, so one batch does not flavor the next.

Where plastic fits

The plastic side of the question has only one stated fact: the FastRack listings call glass a reusable alternative to plastic fermenters. Plastic sizes, weights and included parts are not stated, so a plastic carboy has to be judged on its own listing. For a material comparison on the site, see our plastic vs ceramic fermentation crock comparison.

Sizes, kits and the temperature limit

Size is the first choice: 3 gallon carboys suit smaller batches, and 5 gallon carboys suit larger ones. The Suzile set is the fullest kit, with drilled and undrilled stoppers, a bubble airlock, a handle and a brush about 27.6 inches long for a deep clean. The Ziliny set brings 2 pieces of 3 gallon carboys with stoppers and airlocks for each. The FastRack carboys are single jugs, and their openings fit a #7 stopper, which is sold separately. The FastRack 3 gallon carboy weighs 8.2 lbs when empty and approximately 23.2 lbs when filled, and the Suzile carboy weighs 16.2 pounds. The FastRack 5 gallon states a warranty of 30 days, and the FastRack 3 gallon states a 30 day limited warranty.

The temperature limit matters most. The Suzile and Ziliny listings state soda-lime glass that withstands a maximum temperature of 40 degrees Celsius, and warn that high-temperature sterilization, pouring in hot water, and short-term hot and cold alternation can break the glass. During fermentation, use the venting valve to release air, and do not seal the glass during fermentation. One listing needs a careful read: the Suzile bullets state about 11 by 11 by 19 inches, while the spec table states 21.26 by 13.39 by 12.8 inches, so go by the bullets and check the listing before you buy.

FAQ: preserving at home

Can a glass carboy go in hot water?

No, per the Suzile and Ziliny listings. High-temperature sterilization, pouring in hot water, and short-term hot and cold alternation can break the glass, which withstands a maximum temperature of 40 degrees Celsius.

Do I need a stopper and airlock?

The Suzile and Ziliny sets include drilled and undrilled stoppers and airlocks, while the FastRack carboys state an opening that fits a #7 stopper, with the stopper sold separately. During fermentation, use the venting valve to release air, and do not seal the glass during fermentation.

What size carboy should I pick?

The listings here state 3 gallon and 5 gallon sizes. The FastRack 3 gallon carboy weighs 8.2 lbs when empty and approximately 23.2 lbs when filled, so check the weight and the space before you buy.

Is glass better than plastic for fermenting?

The glass listings state a reusable alternative to plastic fermenters, with a wide mouth that is easy to clean and a seal that keeps air out. The listings state no plastic sizes or included parts, so check the plastic listing for those.

More preserving guides

See every home brewing guide and all food storage guides.

More picks: plastic vs ceramic fermentation crock, how to use an airlock, kombucha dispensers and kombucha dispenser vs swing top bottles.

Read next in the kitchen