On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Le Creuset Butter Crock9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Butter Bell Emerald Crock9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Butter Bell Yellow Café Crock9.7/10View on Amazon - 4
KITCHENDAO Butter Dish9.4/10View on Amazon
A counter full of fresh butter after a morning of churning is the moment a butter bell earns its place. How to set up a butter bell is simple: pour cold water into the crock base, pack softened butter firmly into the lid, and seat the lid in the base so the water seals the butter from air. This guide walks through those steps and compares the crocks and dishes the listings describe, so you can pick the one that fits your counter and your butter.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Le Creuset Butter Crock | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Butter Bell Emerald Crock | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Butter Bell Yellow Café Crock | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | KITCHENDAO Butter Dish | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Le Creuset Butter Crock
A stoneware butter crock with a lifetime warranty that handles the water-seal step for 1-1/2 sticks of butter at the table.
Pros
- Holds 1-1/2 sticks of soft butter, more than the one-stick crocks here
- Non-porous enameled glaze will not absorb odors and resists chipping or staining
- Lifetime warranty is stated
Cons
- No stated water amount for the seal, unlike the Butter Bell listings that state 1/3 cup
- No fired temperature is stated
- Listing states no lead-free or cadmium-free claim

Butter Bell Emerald Crock
A New Bone China butter crock with a water seal that handles the full setup for one stick of butter on the countertop.
Pros
- Water-seal design keeps butter fresh and spreadable without refrigeration
- Dishwasher-safe finish with lead-free, cadmium-free glazes
- 2-year limited warranty is stated
Cons
- Holds exactly one stick, so larger butter blocks need a bigger keeper
- Raised relief antique finish may not suit every kitchen style

Butter Bell Yellow Café Crock
A glossy ceramic butter crock with a water seal that handles countertop butter storage for one stick, no refrigeration needed.
Pros
- Water seal keeps butter fresh and spreadable without refrigeration
- New Bone China ceramic fired at 2200 degrees with a scratch resistant finish
- 2-year limited warranty is stated
Cons
- No dishwasher-safe statement in this listing
- Holds one stick only

KITCHENDAO Butter Dish
A lidded plastic butter dish with a latching buckle that handles countertop butter storage without a water seal.
Pros
- One-press latching buckle locks and unlocks with one hand
- Sealing ring and side ramps help keep butter fresh and make scooping easy
- Dishwasher safe and microwave safe with the lid removed
Cons
- A lidded dish, not a water-seal butter bell crock
- Plastic build rather than ceramic or stoneware
- No warranty term is stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain French Ceramic Butter KeeperCheck price on Amazon
Eichzer Ceramic White Butter Crock with Bell-shaped LidCheck price on Amazon
Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Art Nouveau Ceramic ButterCheck price on Amazon
Gnocchi Boards and Wooden Butter Paddles to Easily CreateCheck price on Amazon
Kilner Beech Wood Butter PaddlesCheck price on Amazon
How to set up a butter bell: the short list
A butter bell setup runs through water, butter and the seal, in that order. The table shows what each step needs.
| Step | What to do | What it needs | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pour water | Pour cold water into the base of the crock | 1/3 cup of cold water | |
| Pack butter | Pack softened butter firmly into the lid | One stick or cube of butter | |
| Seat the lid | Replace the lid into the base | Airtight water seal |
Start with the crock, not the butter
Before you buy, sort the keepers into two groups. A butter bell crock uses a water seal: the lid sits in water in the base, and the water keeps air from the butter. A lidded butter dish uses a lid and a sealing ring instead, with no water step at all. The KITCHENDAO dish (on Amazon) in this guide is that second kind: a plastic dish with a latching buckle and a sealing ring, made for the countertop and the refrigerator door shelf. If you want the water-seal setup, pick a crock; if you want a lidded dish, pick the dish, and do not expect it to seal the way a crock does.
A crock sized by butter
Crock capacity is stated in sticks of butter. The Butter Bell crocks hold one stick or cube, stated as 1/2 cup or 125 grams, and the Le Creuset crock (on Amazon) holds 1-1/2 sticks, stated as 6 ounces. Pick the capacity that matches the butter you keep on the counter, and look for a listing that states the amount rather than leaving you to guess.
Size also decides where the crock sits. The Butter Bell Yellow crock lists 4.0 inches x 4.0 inches x 4.0 inches, the Butter Bell Emerald lists 3.94 inches x 3.94 inches x 4.13 inches, and the Le Creuset lists 4.0 inches x 4.0 inches x 4.5 inches. The KITCHENDAO dish lists 7.8 inches x 3.23 inches x 2.64 inches, a longer, lower shape that suits a refrigerator door shelf. Compare those footprints against the counter space before you buy.
Water, butter and the seal
Pour 1/3 cup of cold water into the base of the crock, as the Butter Bell listings direct. Pack the lid firmly with softened butter, then replace the lid into the base. The water forms an airtight seal that protects the butter and keeps it fresh and spreadable without refrigeration, according to the listings.
For cleaning, the Emerald crock lists a dishwasher-safe finish, the Le Creuset crock is dishwasher-safe, and the KITCHENDAO dish is dishwasher safe. The Yellow crock listing states no dishwasher-safe finish, so check the listing before putting that crock in the dishwasher.
Butter bells we compared
The crocks and dish below cover the water, butter and seal steps above: each one handles countertop butter storage in its own way, and the cards give the listing facts for each keeper.
What to skip or double-check
- A lidded dish is not a butter bell: the KITCHENDAO dish seals with a latching buckle and a sealing ring, not with water, so do not expect a water seal from it.
- Microwave use: the KITCHENDAO dish is microwave safe only with the lid removed before heating, as the listing states.
- Butter amount: the Butter Bell crocks hold one stick, while the Le Creuset holds 1-1/2 sticks, so check the capacity before buying for a household that goes through butter fast.
- Lead and cadmium: the Butter Bell crocks state no lead or cadmium, and the Emerald crock states lead-free, cadmium-free glazes. The Le Creuset listing states no such claim, so check the listing if that matters to you.
What this guide does not cover
This is a setup guide. It does not give recipes, butter-making steps or storage times. Take those from a current edition of a trusted food preservation guide, and follow the crock maker’s directions for your own crock.
FAQ: preserving at home
How much water goes in a butter bell?
Pour 1/3 cup of cold water into the base of the crock, as the Butter Bell listings direct, then pack softened butter firmly into the lid and seat the lid in the base.
How much butter does a butter bell hold?
Each Butter Bell crock holds one stick or cube, stated as 1/2 cup or 125 grams. The Le Creuset crock holds 1-1/2 sticks, stated as 6 ounces.
Does a butter bell need refrigeration?
According to the listings, no. The Butter Bell crocks keep butter fresh and spreadable without refrigeration, and the Le Creuset crock keeps 6 ounces of butter soft and fresh without refrigeration.
Can I put a butter bell in the dishwasher?
The Emerald crock lists a dishwasher-safe finish and the Le Creuset crock is dishwasher-safe. The Yellow crock listing states no dishwasher-safe finish, so check the listing for that crock before washing it in a dishwasher.
Is a lidded butter dish the same as a butter bell?
No. A butter bell uses a water seal, while the KITCHENDAO dish seals with a latching buckle and a sealing ring and has no water step. Pick the crock for the water-seal setup and the dish for a lidded dish.
More preserving guides
See our best butter bell crock picks and the butter bell vs butter keeper crock comparison.
More picks: butter bell crocks, butter keeper crocks, Priority Chef butter crock review and butter bell vs butter churn.





