On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Gemfino 4-piece lid lifter and popper set9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Pisol 3-in-1 magnetic lid lifter9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Pisol 3-in-1 magnetic lid lifter tool9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
4 Pack Canning KitsView on Amazon - 5
PrepWorks Lid LifterView on Amazon
Lid wand vs magnetic lid lifter is a question about two names for tools that handle canning lids, and the short answer is that a magnetic lid lifter is the tool you want for canning day. The Pisol 3-in-1 lists a magnet on the bottom specifically for lifting jar lids from hot water without touching the sealing compound. The Tovolo silicone lifters and the Lodge Dutch oven lifter do different jobs: the Tovolos prop pot lids open to release steam while cooking, and the Lodge lifts heavy Dutch oven lids at a campfire. This guide sorts out which one matches your task.
Runners-up to consider
4 Pack Canning KitsCheck price on Amazon
PrepWorks Lid LifterCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Lid wand vs magnetic lid lifter: what each tool does
A magnetic lid lifter, sometimes called a lid wand, is a canning tool. The Pisol lists a powerful magnet on the bottom that picks up flat canning lids from a pan of hot water, so your fingers never touch the sealing compound. It also lists a bubble popper tip and measure marks for headspace, making it a 3-in-1 tool. The listing describes it as 9.06 by 1.38 by 0.6 in, weighing 2.89 ounces, in a 4-piece set.
The Tovolo Farm Animals and Sheep lifters are not for canning lids. They are silicone figures that slide onto a pot rim to prop the lid open a crack, letting steam escape while soups and sauces simmer. Both list BPA-free silicone that withstands up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher-safe cleanup, and a set of 3. The Farm Animals set includes a rooster, pig and sheep; the Sheep set is all sheep in black and white.
The Lodge Deluxe is a different tool entirely. It is a 16-inch steel lifter for camp Dutch ovens, with a squeeze grip that locks onto the lid so you can lift it off an open flame and carry the oven to the table. The listing describes 9 mm bar stock with a high-temperature black finish, weighing 1.2 pounds. It pairs with Lodge 5-quart and 10-quart camp Dutch ovens.
The gear, ranked for canning
For the specific job of handling canning lids, the ranking is clear:
1. Pisol Magnetic 3-in-1. The only one of the four designed for canning lids. The magnet lifts lids from hot water, the tip pops bubbles, and the measure marks check headspace. The 4-piece set means you have spares. At 9.06 in long, it reaches into a pan without your hand going near the water.
2. Tovolo Farm Animals Set of 3. Not for canning, but useful on canning day for the cooking that happens alongside it. The silicone figures prop lids on stockpots and saucepans while you prep jam or sauce. The set of 3 covers multiple pots. BPA-free silicone to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher safe.
3. Tovolo Sheep Set of 3. Same function as the Farm Animals set, in a sheep design. The listing describes the same BPA-free silicone, 600-degree rating and dishwasher-safe cleanup. Pick the design you prefer; the function is identical.
4. Lodge Deluxe 16-inch. The right tool if you cook over a campfire in a Dutch oven, but overkill for a kitchen canning setup. The 16-inch length and squeeze grip are designed for open-flame cooking, not for lifting flat canning lids from a pan. The listing notes hand-wash-only care.
When you need the magnetic lifter
If you water-bath or pressure-can, you need a way to get sterilized flat lids out of hot water without touching the sealing ring. Fingers leave oils that can interfere with the seal, and tongs can scratch the compound. The Pisol’s magnet solves this by picking the lid up from below. The listing describes the magnet as powerful enough to lift lids easily.
The 3-in-1 design adds the bubble popper and headspace measurer, two tools you would otherwise buy separately. The bubble popper tip releases trapped air from filled jars, and the measure marks help you match the headspace your recipe specifies. For a beginner setting up a first canning kit, this covers three tools in one. See our best magnetic lid lifter for canning comparison for more options, and the magnetic lid lifter vs jar lifter guide if you are deciding between the two.
When the silicone lifters make sense
The Tovolo lifters earn their place on canning day in a supporting role. While a batch processes, you are often cooking the next batch of jam, sauce or brine on the stove. Propping the lid open with a silicone figure prevents boilovers without you standing over the pot. The BPA-free silicone to 600 degrees Fahrenheit handles simmering pots, and the dishwasher-safe cleanup means no extra scrubbing.
They also double as tea bag holders, per both listings, holding the string to the side of a mug. This is a nice extra but not a reason to buy them for canning. Buy them if you want the steam-vent function for everyday cooking; do not buy them expecting to lift canning lids.
What about the Lodge?
The Lodge Deluxe is a campfire tool. If your canning happens in a kitchen with a stove, it has no role. If you cook in a Dutch oven over an open flame, the 16-inch length keeps your hands away from the heat, and the squeeze grip locks onto the lid. The listing describes it as protecting hands from open flame. For kitchen canning, skip it.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Use the magnetic lifter for canning lids; do not substitute tongs or fingers.
- Check that the Pisol magnet picks up your lid size before canning day.
- Keep silicone lifters away from direct flame; they are rated to 600 degrees Fahrenheit for pot rims, not open fire.
- Hand-wash the Lodge lifter per the listing; do not put it in the dishwasher.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is a lid wand the same as a magnetic lid lifter?
In canning, the terms are often used for the same tool: a wand with a magnet that lifts flat lids from hot water. The Pisol lists itself as a magnetic jar lid lifter, which is the canning tool.
Can I use the Tovolo silicone lifters for canning lids?
No. They are designed to prop pot lids open for steam release during cooking, not to pick up flat canning lids from hot water. Use the magnetic lifter for canning lids.
Do I need a lid lifter if I have a jar lifter?
They do different jobs. A jar lifter grips hot jars; a magnetic lid lifter picks up flat lids. Most canners use both. See the magnetic lid lifter vs jar lifter guide for the full comparison.
How many lid lifters do I need?
One magnetic lifter is enough for canning. The Pisol comes as a 4-piece set, and the Tovolo sets come as 3, so you have spares or can share.
More preserving guides
See every canning tools guide and all canning guides.
More picks: magnetic lid lifter for canning and canning tool kits.





