Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Magnetic Lid Lifter vs Jar Lifter: Which One Should You Buy?
Canning

Magnetic Lid Lifter vs Jar Lifter: Which One Should You Buy?

Magnetic lid lifter vs jar lifter: canning tool listings compared by size and use, with how to choose for canning.

On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Pisol 3-in-1 magnetic lid lifterPisol 3-in-1 magnetic lid lifter9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Gemfino 4pc Canning Tool Kit with Jar LifterGemfino 4pc Canning Tool Kit with Jar Lifter9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Pisol Canning Magnetic Jar Lid Lifter and Bubble PopperPisol Canning Magnetic Jar Lid Lifter and Bubble Popper9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4PrepWorks Lid LifterPrepWorks Lid LifterView on Amazon
  5. 54 Pack Canning Kits4 Pack Canning KitsView on Amazon
  6. 6Norpro Canning Jar Lifter Features cushion coating to improveNorpro Canning Jar Lifter Features cushion coating to improveView on Amazon
  7. 7Canning Jar Lifter TongsCanning Jar Lifter TongsView on Amazon
  8. 8Rainspire Stainless Steel Canning Jar LifterRainspire Stainless Steel Canning Jar LifterView on Amazon
  9. 9Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Canning Jar Lifter Tongs for PressureMrs. Anderson’s Baking Canning Jar Lifter Tongs for PressureView on Amazon

The magnetic lid lifter vs jar lifter question is about lids against jars: a magnetic lid lifter picks flat lids from simmering water, while a jar lifter grips hot jars to lift them from the canner. You need both for canning. This guide explains each using figures from canning tool listings.

Runners-up to consider

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Magnetic lid lifter vs jar lifter: the short answer

Buy a magnetic lid lifter for lids and a jar lifter for jars: they do different jobs. The PrepWorks lid lifter is 7.31 by 0.75 by 0.75 in with a strong magnet for lids from simmering water. The Gemfino 4-piece kit includes a stainless steel jar lifter for hot jars plus a magnetic lid lifter. Every number below comes from one of these listings.

How a magnetic lid lifter works

Lids without burns

A magnetic lid lifter uses a magnet to lift flat canning lids from hot water. The PrepWorks lifter is 7.31 by 0.75 by 0.75 in at 1.13 ounces with an ergonomic handle. The ZZLZX lifter is 6.7 in long and comes 4 to a pack. The HONSNKS lid lifter is 6.89 in long. For jar lifter picks, see our best jar lifter for canning.

Combo tools

Many listings bundle the lifter with a bubble popper: the Pisol 3-in-1 is 9.84 by 2.36 by 0.59 in with measure marks for headspace. The Gemfino 2-plus-2 kit and the HONSNKS 2-piece kit pair a lid lifter with a bubble popper. The CNYMANY 7-piece kit adds a funnel and spatulas. These combos cover the whole lid and jar prep routine.

How a jar lifter works

Jars without burns

A jar lifter is a tong that grips the jar below the rim to lift it from boiling water. The Gemfino 4-piece kit includes a stainless steel jar lifter with heat-resistant rubber, per its listing. It is the tool that moves the full, hot jar to the counter. For wide-mouth picks, see our best jar lifter for wide mouth jars.

When each wins

The lid lifter wins for lids: it fishes flat lids from simmering water without tongs slipping. The jar lifter wins for jars: no magnet can lift a full quart jar. Neither replaces the other, and most kits include both. For quart picks, see our best jar lifter for quart jars.

What this guide does not cover

This guide does not cover can openers with magnetic lid lifters, which are for cans, not canning lids. It does not cover jar openers that release vacuum seals, like the LXLO listing. It does not cover pressure canners themselves. For canner guides, see our pressure canner articles.

Choosing the right lifting tools

Singles, packs or kits

Lid lifters come solo or in packs. The PrepWorks lifter is one tool at 7.31 by 0.75 by 0.75 in and 1.13 ounces, while the ZZLZX comes 4 to a pack at 6.7 in long. A 4-pack suits a busy canning kitchen, or as spares. Kits bundle the lifter with a bubble popper: the Gemfino 2-plus-2, the HONSNKS 2-piece and the Pisol 3-in-1 all pair the two tools, and the CNYMANY 7-piece adds a funnel and spatulas.

Lengths and reach

Reach matters over a deep canner. The PrepWorks measures 7.31 in long, the HONSNKS 6.89 in, the ZZLZX 6.7 in, and the Pisol 3-in-1 stretches to 9.84 in. The HONSNKS bubble popper is 8.86 in long, and both it and the Pisol carry measure marks for headspace. Longer tools keep hands further from simmering water.

Materials and care

The Gemfino 4-piece kit lists a stainless steel jar lifter with heat-resistant rubber and a high-temperature resistant plastic lid lifter with a hook for storage. The Gemfino 2-plus-2 listing says the tools can be cleaned and reused. Rinse the magnet after use so food does not dry on it.

In the Preserving Kitchen

  • Keep the magnetic lid lifter in the simmering water pot for quick lid pickup.
  • Grip jars below the rim with the jar lifter, never by the lid.
  • Rinse the magnet after use; the listings state the lifters clean and reuse.
  • Store the lifter by its hook, per the Gemfino listing.

FAQ: preserving at home

Do I need both a lid lifter and a jar lifter?

Yes. The lid lifter picks flat lids from hot water; the jar lifter moves full hot jars. Most kits, like the Gemfino 4-piece, include both.

How long are these lifters?

The PrepWorks is 7.31 in, the ZZLZX 6.7 in, and the HONSNKS lid lifter 6.89 in. The Pisol 3-in-1 is 9.84 in long.

Can a magnetic lid lifter lift a jar?

No. It lifts flat lids only. Use the jar lifter tongs for full hot jars.

Which kits include a bubble popper?

The Pisol 3-in-1, the Gemfino 2-plus-2, the HONSNKS 2-piece and the CNYMANY 7-piece all include a bubble popper with the lid lifter.

More preserving guides

See every canning guide.

More picks: Ball jar lifters, jar lifters for small jars and jar lifter vs canning tongs.

Read next in the kitchen