Skip to content
Independent guides to preserving gear, est. 2026

Canning, drying, storing and harvest gear for home kitchens

We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals
Reusable vs Metal Canning Lids: Which One Should You Buy?
Canning

Reusable vs Metal Canning Lids: Which One Should You Buy?

Reusable lids are stated indefinitely reusable for water bath and pressure canning; metal lids are single use. Figures from the listings to help you choose.

On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Ball Wide Mouth Mason Jars 16 ozBall Wide Mouth Mason Jars 16 oz9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Tattler Reusable Wide Mouth Canning Lids & Rubber RingsTattler Reusable Wide Mouth Canning Lids & Rubber RingsView on Amazon
  3. 3Authentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids WIDE MouthAuthentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids WIDE MouthView on Amazon
  4. 4Authentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning LidsAuthentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning LidsView on Amazon
  5. 5Reusable Canning Lids 18/8 Premium Stainless Steel Mason JarReusable Canning Lids 18/8 Premium Stainless Steel Mason JarView on Amazon
  6. 6Authentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids Combo Pack 3Authentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids Combo Pack 3View on Amazon
  7. 7Authentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids 50 Bulk WIDEAuthentic Tattler E-Z Seal Reusable Canning Lids 50 Bulk WIDEView on Amazon

Reusable vs metal canning lids comes down to how many seasons you want from each lid. Choose reusable lids like Tattler when you can year after year and want to stop buying lids every season; choose standard metal lids when you want the simplest option and accept single use. The listings state Tattler lids are indefinitely reusable and rated for both hot water bath and pressure canning, while metal lids like Dalzom’s are stated one-time use with reusable rings. Every figure below comes from the reference listings.

Runners-up to consider

HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Reusable canning lids

Reusable lids are built to survive processing again and again. The Tattler wide mouth 12-pack listing states BPA-free lids that are indefinitely reusable, dishwasher safe, made from FDA-approved materials, and rated for use with a pressure canner or water bath. The Tattler E-Z Seal listing, in 144-packs for wide and regular mouth, repeats the indefinitely reusable claim, adds made in the USA, and states no food spoilage due to acid corrosion. The SUNIVALE kit states 24 wide mouth Tattler lids and rings with dissolvable labels, BPA-free plastic lids and latex-free rubber rings, made in the USA, for hot water bath and pressure canning, at a stated per-lid price. The UPTRUST 12-pack states food-grade 18/8 304 stainless steel lids, 86mm wide mouth, anti-rust, dishwasher safe and reusable across high and low temperatures.

Standard metal canning lids

Standard metal lids are the familiar flat lids with sealing compound, meant for one use. The Dalzom set states 24 lids plus 24 rings for wide mouth jars in food-grade tinplate with BPA-free silicone seals, and states plainly that rings are reusable while lids are for one-time use only. The Aliggbent 220-pack states 70mm tinplate lids, BPA-free and food grade, rustproof, and reusable for dry storage, though not for re-canning. The PullCrease 120-packs state tinplate lids in 86mm and 70mm, rust resistant and reusable for storage and gifts. Metal lids are simple and widely available; their limit is the single-use seal.

Reusable vs metal canning lids: head to head

Aspect Reusable (Tattler, UPTRUST, SUNIVALE) Metal (Dalzom, Aliggbent, PullCrease)
Reuse for canning Indefinitely reusable, stated Lids one-time use, stated
Canning methods Water bath and pressure canning stated Water bath canning stated
Materials stated BPA-free plastic; 18/8 stainless Tinplate with silicone seals
Acid corrosion Tattler states no spoilage from acid corrosion Not stated
Pack sizes 12, 24 and 144 packs stated 24, 120 and 220 packs stated
Cost framing Per-lid price stated (SUNIVALE) Not stated per lid

Every figure in the table comes from the reference listings. Where a listing states nothing, the table leaves it unclear.

Which should you buy?

Buy reusable if

  • You can every season and want to stop buying lids; Tattler states indefinitely reusable.
  • You pressure can as well as water bath; the Tattler listings state both methods.
  • You can acidic foods and worry about corrosion; Tattler states no spoilage from acid corrosion.
  • You like the math: the SUNIVALE kit frames Tattler lids at a stated per-lid price for a lifetime supply.

Buy metal if

  • You want the simplest, most familiar system: new lid each batch, reusable ring.
  • You can in big batches; the Aliggbent 220-pack and PullCrease 120-packs are sized for it.
  • You want decorative or gift jars; the PullCrease stained-glass styles suit that.
  • You accept single use: Dalzom states lids are for one-time use only.

What the listings say about reuse

The listings draw a clear line. Dalzom states rings are reusable and lids are for one-time use only. Aliggbent states its tinplate lids are reusable for dry storage, which is storage, not re-canning. Tattler states its lids are indefinitely reusable for actual canning, including pressure canning. Do not confuse the two kinds of reuse: a lid that survives the pantry is not automatically a lid that seals a second batch.

Pair the right lids with the right jars: our best canning jars for salsa and best canning jars for tomato sauce guides cover jar choices, and our single piece vs two piece canning lids guide covers lid styles.

FAQ: preserving at home

Are Tattler lids safe for pressure canning?

Yes, per the listings. The Tattler wide mouth and E-Z Seal listings state use with a pressure canner or water bath, and the SUNIVALE kit repeats hot water bath and pressure canning.

How many times can metal lids be reused for canning?

Once. Dalzom states lids are for one-time use only, with rings reusable. Aliggbent states its lids are reusable for dry storage, not for re-canning.

Do reusable lids cost more?

Per lid over time, less. The SUNIVALE kit frames Tattler lids at a stated per-lid price for what it calls a lifetime supply, against buying metal lids every season.

More preserving guides

See every canning guide. Also see our single piece vs two piece canning lids. Also see our best canning jars for salsa.

More picks: canning.

Read next in the kitchen