On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Ninja JC151 Cold Press Juicer9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
COSTWAY Steam Juicer 11-Quart9.4/10View on Amazon - 3
Zulay Cast Iron Citrus Press9.4/10View on Amazon - 4
Aufranc 5-Quart Steam Pot9.3/10View on Amazon
This steam juicer vs fruit press comparison pits two ways of getting juice from your harvest head to head. Verdict: pick a steam juicer if you want to extract juice from bulk fruit for canning jelly and juice; pick a fruit press if you want to press citrus or make fresh juice by the glass. We compared four listings, two per side, by harvest fit, contents, value and warranty.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
| Model | Shelf Score | Side | Type | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ninja JC151 Cold Press Juicer | 9.5/10 | Fruit press | Electric | 150W, 24 oz | View on Amazon |
| COSTWAY Steam Juicer 11-Quart | 9.4/10 | Steam juicer | Stovetop | 11 qt, 304 SS | View on Amazon |
| Zulay Cast Iron Citrus Press | 9.4/10 | Fruit press | Manual | 5 in bowl | View on Amazon |
| Aufranc 5-Quart Steam Pot | 9.3/10 | Steam juicer | Stovetop | 5 qt, stainless | View on Amazon |
steam juicer vs fruit press: the short version
| # | Product | Harvest Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ninja JC151 Cold Press Juicer | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | COSTWAY Steam Juicer 11-Quart | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Zulay Cast Iron Citrus Press | 9.4/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | Aufranc 5-Quart Steam Pot | 9.3/10 | Buy on Amazon |
Pros
- 150-watt high-torque motor for fibrous fruits and vegetables
- Total pulp control with 2 interchangeable filters
- 24-ounce juice jug and 36-ounce pulp container
- 1 Year Limited Warranty stated
Cons
- 24-ounce jug only; not for bulk batches
- Electric only; needs an outlet
- No stated juice yield per batch
- 7.9 pounds on the counter
Pros
- 11-quart capacity for bulk juice extraction
- 304 stainless steel with 3-layer composite bottom
- Silicone hose with clamp for juice outflow
- No peeling, squeezing or straining needed
Cons
- No juice yield per batch stated
- No warranty term stated
- Needs a stove; not electric
- Large to store

Zulay Cast Iron Citrus Press
A manual cast iron citrus press; skip it for vegetables or bulk batches.
Pros
- Heavy-duty cast iron with lever arm
- 5-inch bowl handles limes to grapefruits
- No electricity or batteries needed
- Hand wash only; simple care
Cons
- Citrus only; not for vegetables
- 15.1 pounds; heavy on the counter
- No warranty term stated
- Manual; slower than electric
Pros
- 5-quart stockpot with two 2-quart steamer baskets
- Food grade stainless steel, no coating
- Stackable design saves kitchen space
- Glass lid locks in flavor and moisture
Cons
- Not a dedicated juicer; a general steamer
- No warranty term stated
- Needs a stove; not electric
- 5.5 lbs stacked weight
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
Hurom H400 Easy Clean Slow JuicerCheck price on Amazon
Hurom H70 Cold Press Juicer MachineCheck price on Amazon
Hurom H330 Cold Press Juicer MachineCheck price on Amazon
Aeitto 3-in-1 Juicer MachinesCheck price on Amazon
VIVOHOME 11 Qt Stainless Steel Steam Juicer for Canning FruitCheck price on Amazon
VIVOHOME Stainless Steel Steam Juicer for Canning Fruit andCheck price on Amazon
What separates the two sides
How they work
The steam juicer side uses steam to extract juice: the COSTWAY example is an 11-quart steam juicer with a tempered glass lid, a pan, a steamer and a large bottom pot. You fill the bottom pan with water, put fruit in the top strainer, and juice flows out through a silicone hose with a clamp. No peeling, squeezing or straining is needed, per the listing. The Aufranc example is a 5-quart steamer set with two 2-quart steamer baskets and a glass lid, built for steaming vegetables and slow cooking as well as general cooking.
The fruit press side
The fruit press side squeezes juice mechanically. The Zulay Kitchen example is a cast iron manual citrus press with a 5-inch bowl and lever arm, weighing 15.1 pounds. The Ninja example is a 150-watt electric cold press juicer with a high-torque auger, a 24-ounce juice jug and a 36-ounce pulp container. The Ninja example states a 1 Year Limited Warranty.
What stays unclear
Neither steam juicer listing states a juice yield per batch, so you cannot compare extraction rates. The fruit press side gives no wattage for the Zulay manual press and no stated juice yield per fruit for the Ninja. Neither the COSTWAY nor the Aufranc listing states a warranty term. So do not call either side more efficient on yield: the listings leave that unclear.
Who should pick a steam juicer
Pick a steam juicer if you process bulk fruit for canning: the COSTWAY 11-quart example is built for jelly, jam and juice extraction. The Aufranc 5-quart example suits smaller batches and doubles as a steamer. For more options, see our best steam juicer guide.
Who should pick a fruit press
Pick a fruit press if you juice by the glass: the Zulay press handles citrus from limes to grapefruits, and the Ninja cold press juicer handles fruits and vegetables with pulp control. Learn more in our best electric tomato juicer for canning guide.
Before you buy
- Choose steam for bulk canning or a press for fresh juice by the glass.
- Check capacity: 11 quarts vs 24 ounces is a big gap.
- Manual presses need no power; electric ones need an outlet.
FAQ: preserving at home
Do I need to peel fruit for a steam juicer?
No. The COSTWAY listing states there is no need to peel, squeeze or strain the fruit.
What warranty does the Ninja state?
A 1 Year Limited Warranty, per the listing.
How big is the Zulay press bowl?
5 inches in diameter, per the listing.
More preserving guides
See every cider and fruit press guide and all harvest and processing guides.








