On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
All American 910 10.5-Quart9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
McSunley 21.5-Quart Water Bath9.4/10View on Amazon
The water bath canner vs pressure canner choice is decided less by the pot and more by what you plan to put in the jars. A water bath canner, like the McSunley 21.5 quart stainless pot, holds jars in boiling water and suits high-acid foods such as jams, jellies, pickles and acidified tomatoes. A pressure canner, like the All American 910, traps steam to reach temperatures above boiling, which current USDA guidance requires for low-acid vegetables, meat, poultry and seafood. We compared one listing of each type, looking strictly at what each Amazon listing publishes.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose a water bath canner if your harvest goes into jams, jellies, pickles and salsa; the McSunley example holds 7 quart jars per load and weighs 8.5 pounds empty. Choose a pressure canner if you want to can green beans, corn, stock or meat; the All American 910 example holds about 7 pint jars or 4 quart jars and seals without a gasket. Many home canners end up with both, because neither pot covers the other’s job in these listings.
Two examples

All American 910 10.5-Quart
A 10.5 quart cast aluminum pressure canner and cooker that holds about 7 pint jars or 4 quart jars, with a gasket-free metal-to-metal seal.
Pros
- Pressure canner for low-acid foods, holds about 7 pint jars or 4 quart jars
- Metal-to-metal seal with positive action clamping locks, no gasket to replace
- Steam gauge and precision machined regulator weight for pressure control
- Cast aluminum, made in the USA, for gas, electric and flat-top stoves
Cons
- 4 quart jars per load is a small batch for a large harvest
- Weighs 14.8 pounds empty, heavier than the 8.5 pound McSunley pot
- No warranty term is stated

McSunley 21.5-Quart Water Bath
A 21.5 quart stainless steel water bath canner with an aluminum encapsulated base, a lift-out jar rack and a tempered glass lid.
Pros
- Rack holds 7 quart jars, 9 pint jars or 12 half-pint jars
- Stainless steel pot with an aluminum encapsulated base for gas, electric and glass tops
- Rack rests on the pot sides so jars load before lowering into the water
- Tempered glass lid and riveted stainless handles that stay cool
Cons
- For high-acid foods only, it cannot replace a pressure canner
- The listing does not mention induction cooktops
- No warranty term is stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Runners-up to consider
25 Quart Pressure Canner Cooker & pressure canners forCheck price on Amazon
Ball EasyCanner Electric Water Bath CannerCheck price on Amazon
Electric Water Bath Canner 27 QuartCheck price on Amazon
24.5QT Electric Water Bath CannerCheck price on Amazon
15 quart Jar Stove Top Water Bath CannerCheck price on Amazon
Presto 01781 23-Quart Pressure Canner and CookerCheck price on Amazon
Water bath canner vs pressure canner: side by side
| Canner | Harvest Score | Canner Type | Capacity | Jar Capacity | Material | Lid and Seal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All American 910 10.5-Quart | 9.7/10 | Pressure canner | 10.5 quarts | About 7 pint or 4 quart jars | Cast aluminum | Metal-to-metal seal, clamping locks |
| McSunley 21.5-Quart Water Bath | 9.6/10 | Water bath canner | 21.5 quarts | 7 quart, 9 pint or 12 half-pint jars | Stainless steel, aluminum base | Tempered glass lid |
We list the manufacturer’s stated figures without changes, as of 15 October 2026.
What each canner is for
The line between the two types is acidity. High-acid foods, including most fruits, jams, jellies, pickles and tomatoes with added acid, can be processed in a boiling water bath when you follow a current USDA recipe. Low-acid foods, including plain vegetables, meat, poultry, seafood and stock, need a pressure canner, because boiling water alone does not get hot enough for them. The All American 910 listing explains the idea in its own words: a pressure canner traps steam, which drives the boiling point of water past 212°F.
Never use a water bath canner for low-acid foods, and never treat a pressure cooker as a canner unless the maker states it is for canning. Processing times, pressures and altitude changes are not covered here; take them from current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation recipes for each food. Our canning section groups every canner and tool guide in one place.
Capacity and jar count
Volume alone does not tell you much, so look for the jar count. The McSunley rack holds 7 one-quart jars, 9 one-pint jars or 12 half-pint jars in a 21.5 quart pot. The All American 910 is listed at 10.5 quarts and holds approximately 7 pint jars or 4 quart jars. The McSunley fits more of both: 9 pint jars against about 7, and 7 quart jars against 4.
If you want a pressure canner with more room for quart jars, the All American line goes much larger; our All American 941 review covers the 41.5 quart model, and the best pressure canner guide compares other sizes, including digital models.
Lids, seals and controls
A water bath canner only needs a lid that keeps the steam in while the water boils. The McSunley uses a tempered glass lid that the listing calls shatter-resistant, so you can watch the boil without lifting it, and riveted stainless handles that stay cool.
A pressure canner has to lock shut and show you the pressure inside. The All American 910 uses a precision machined metal-to-metal seal with positive action clamping locks instead of a rubber gasket, an easy-to-read steam gauge and a precision machined regulator weight, and the spec table adds an over pressure plug. That extra hardware is what makes a pressure canner heavier and more involved to run, and it is why the maker’s manual matters more here than with a boiling pot.
Stove fit, weight and storage
McSunley states its flat, aluminum encapsulated base works on gas, electric and smooth glass top ranges and spreads heat to limit hot spots and jar breakage. The All American 910 title names gas, electric and flat-top stoves. Neither listing mentions induction, so check with the maker if that is your cooktop.
Empty weights differ: 8.5 pounds for the McSunley and 14.8 pounds for the cast aluminum All American. The McSunley spec table lists 14 by 12.5 by 16.5 inch dimensions. The All American table lists 10.25 by 10.25 by 11.75 inches, the same figures the much larger 941 listing shows, so treat that size as unconfirmed. Off season, the McSunley also works as a large stockpot.
Listing gaps to check
Neither listing states a warranty term. The McSunley warranty field reads only Warranty, and the All American listing shows none. Both spec tables contain errors: McSunley lists a Non-Stick finish for a stainless steel pot, and All American lists a Touch control method and Automatic operation mode for a manual stovetop canner. The All American bullets also say pressure canning is the only safe way to can fruit, which is broader than current USDA guidance for high-acid fruit. In each case we trusted the title and bullets over the spec table.
Which should you choose?
Choose a water bath canner if you mostly make jams, jellies, pickles, relish and salsa, you want the lightest and simplest setup, and you like a pot that doubles as a stockpot. Compare more options in our best water bath canner guide.
Choose a pressure canner if you want to preserve green beans, corn, potatoes, stock or meat, which a water bath cannot handle. Start with the pressure canners section to match size to your batches.
Whichever you pick, add a jar lifter, funnel and lid lifter; our best canning tool kit comparison covers those.
In the Preserving Kitchen
- Sort your recipes into high-acid and low-acid before buying, so you know whether you need one canner or both.
- Load the McSunley rack while it rests on the pot rim, then lower the 7 quart jars together instead of placing them one by one in boiling water.
- Keep the All American regulator weight with the canner between batches, and read the manual’s venting and cool-down steps before the first load.
- Check the McSunley glass lid and the All American sealing edges for chips or dents before each canning season.
How the Harvest Score played out
| Product | Harvest Score | Perf. | Build | Value | Safety | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All American 910 10.5-Quart | 70 | 25 | 18 | 15 | 12 | 0 |
| McSunley 21.5-Quart Water Bath | 68 | 25 | 17 | 18 | 8 | 0 |
The Harvest Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For canners, safety covers the stated features that keep jars and pressure under control: the gauge, regulator weight and over pressure plug on the All American, and the jar rack and cool handles on the McSunley. The All American scores higher on build and safety for its cast body and pressure controls, while the McSunley scores higher on value for its larger quart jar load. Neither earns warranty points because neither states a term. How we pick explains the weights.
FAQ: preserving at home
Can you use a pressure canner as a water bath canner?
Some pressure canners state that they double as boiling water canners, but the All American 910 listing does not. Check the manual for your model before using it that way, and follow a current USDA boiling water recipe if it is allowed.
Can you can vegetables in a water bath canner?
Not plain low-acid vegetables. Current USDA guidance calls for a pressure canner for green beans, corn and other low-acid vegetables. Pickled vegetables made with a current USDA high-acid recipe are the exception that a water bath canner like the McSunley can handle.
How many jars fit in each canner?
The McSunley rack holds 7 quart jars, 9 pint jars or 12 half-pint jars in its 21.5 quart pot. The All American 910 holds approximately 7 pint jars or 4 quart jars at 10.5 quarts.
Do you need a pressure canner for tomatoes?
Not always. Current USDA tomato recipes include boiling water options with added acid as well as pressure options. Follow the recipe you are using exactly, and keep a pressure canner for plain vegetables, stock and meat.
Does the All American 910 need a replacement gasket?
No. The listing describes a precision machined metal-to-metal seal held by positive action clamping locks, with no gasket. The McSunley water bath canner has no seal at all, only a tempered glass lid.
More preserving guides
See every water bath canners guide, every pressure canners guide and all canning guides.
More picks: water bath canners, pressure canners, All American 941 review and canning tool kits.





