On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
All American 1930 Pressure Cooker/Canner9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
All American 930 Canner9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
All American 1930 Pressure Cooker/Canner9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
All AmericanView on Amazon - 5
All American 1930 Pressure Cooker/CannerView on Amazon - 6
All American pressure cooker regulator weight.View on Amazon - 7
All American 1930 Steam GaugeView on Amazon - 8
All American 1930View on Amazon
All american 910 vs 915 has a short answer and an awkward one: none of the listings in this guide is an All American 910 or 915 canner model, so a spec-by-spec comparison of those two models is not possible from the listings at hand. The closest All American canner listing here is the 921, and the rest of this guide ranks every listing by how close it comes to the question, and flags the two listings that are not canning gear at all.
Runners-up to consider
All AmericanCheck price on Amazon
All American 1930 Pressure Cooker/CannerCheck price on Amazon
All American pressure cooker regulator weight.Check price on Amazon
All American 1930 Steam GaugeCheck price on Amazon
All American 1930Check price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
All American 910 vs 915: what the listings show
Four listings, four different things. One is a canner, one is a canner part, one is a wooden shelf and one is a book. That spread is why this guide cannot crown a winner between the 910 and the 915: neither model appears here. If you are set on one of those two models, use the model number on the listing as your filter, and compare capacity and fittings from the listing itself rather than from a roundup. For safe canning practice, follow current USDA and National Center for Home Food Preservation guidance, and a current edition of a trusted canning guide, exactly for each food.
The gear in these listings, ranked
1. All American 1930 Pressure Canner 921, 21.5 Qt
The All American 1930 Pressure Canner 921, 21.5 Qt is the only full canner in these listings, and it ranks first on relevance alone. The listing gives only its title, so the capacity of 21.5 Qt is the only specification stated; no dimensions, materials or included parts are listed. Treat it as the closest match to the question, not as a confirmed substitute for a 910 or a 915: compare the model number and the stated capacity against the listing you actually buy.
2. All American 1930 Steam Gauge 72 for Pressure Canners, 1/8-Inch NPT
The All American 1930 Steam Gauge 72 for Pressure Canners, 1/8-Inch NPT is a part, not a canner. Its title states a 1/8-inch NPT fitting, and nothing further is listed: no pressure range, no materials, no compatibility list. It ranks second because it belongs to the canner world, but it only makes sense if you already own a canner with a matching fitting, so check the fitting size on your canner before buying.
3. Modern Timber Craft Reclaimed Wood Fireplace Mantel Shelf
The Modern Timber Craft Reclaimed Wood Fireplace Mantel Shelf is the fullest listing here and the least relevant to the question. It is a handcrafted shelf of reclaimed barnwood from Pennsylvania, New York, Eastern Maryland and nearby states, with angle brackets included and support for shelves up to 25 lbs with minimal drilling using a 1/8-inch drill bit. Note a contradiction in the listing: the title lists a length of 910 inches, while the spec table lists 95 inches long by 10 inches deep by 2.75 inches high, and the model number 3x10x95UF agrees with the spec table. It is home decor, not canning gear, and it ranks here only because its title carries the 910 figure.
4. All American Boys
All American Boys is a book, not gear. The listing gives no description and only a release date of September 29, 2015, so there is nothing to compare against a canner. It shares the All American name and nothing else, and it ranks last for a buyer shopping for a canner.
What to check before you buy
- Confirm the model number on the listing: the canner here is the 921, not a 910 or a 915.
- Compare stated capacity: only the 921 listing states one, at 21.5 Qt.
- For parts, match the fitting: the gauge listing states a 1/8-inch NPT fitting and nothing else.
- Set aside keyword matches that are not gear: the mantel shelf and the book share a name or a figure with the question, not a function.
FAQ: preserving at home
Which is better, the All American 910 or the 915?
The listings here include neither model, so this guide cannot rank them. The closest canner listing is the 921 at 21.5 Qt.
Is the 921 a substitute for a 910 or a 915?
The 921 listing gives only its title and capacity, so this guide cannot confirm a match. Compare the model number and capacity on the listing you buy.
Will the steam gauge fit my canner?
The gauge listing states a 1/8-inch NPT fitting and nothing further, so check the fitting size on your canner first.
Why is a mantel shelf in a canner guide?
Its title carries the 910 figure, which matched the question, but it is a reclaimed wood shelf, not canning gear, and this guide ranks it below the canner items.
More preserving guides
See every canning guide.
More picks: pressure canners, water bath canners, water bath vs pressure canner and canning tool kits.





