On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Zazolyne 3 Piece Airlock 4 Pack with Grommets for Carboy and9.4/10View on Amazon - 2
3 Gallon Clear Glass Italian CarboyView on Amazon - 3
Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy SetView on Amazon - 4
Suzile 3 Gallon Glass Carboy Set with StoppersView on Amazon - 5
2.5 Gallon Plastic Dispenser Carboy & SpigotView on Amazon - 6
Carboy Cap- 3View on Amazon - 7
North Mountain Supply Glass Carboy Fermenting JugView on Amazon
A shelf of juice waiting to become cider is where the carboy vs cider jug question usually shows up. The short answer is that a carboy is a large fermenting vessel and a cider jug is a smaller vessel: both hold liquid while it ferments, and the difference sits in the size, the mouth and the fittings that come with each. This guide explains both names, then lines up the vessels from the listings in ranked order, so you can match a vessel to the batch you brew.
Runners-up to consider
3 Gallon Clear Glass Italian CarboyCheck price on Amazon
Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy SetCheck price on Amazon
Suzile 3 Gallon Glass Carboy Set with StoppersCheck price on Amazon
2.5 Gallon Plastic Dispenser Carboy & SpigotCheck price on Amazon
Carboy Cap- 3Check price on Amazon
North Mountain Supply Glass Carboy Fermenting JugCheck price on Amazon
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Carboy vs cider jug: the short answer
A carboy is the big glass fermenter, usually 5 gallons, with a narrow mouth that takes a stopper and an airlock. A cider jug is a smaller glass vessel, often 1 gallon, with the same job on a smaller batch: hold juice or cider while it ferments, then store it. The names overlap at the edges, since a jug can serve as a small carboy, but the listings here draw the line by size: the carboys hold 5 gallons and the jug holds 1 gallon.
The table below sums up the two names as the listings use them.
| Name | What it means | Usual size | Usual fittings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carboy | A large fermenting vessel | 5 gallons | Stopper and airlock |
| Cider jug | A smaller fermenting and storage vessel | 1 gallon | Bung, airlock and cap |
Size is the first choice, and fittings are the second. A 5 gallon carboy suits a large batch of beer, wine, cider or mead, while a 1 gallon jug suits a small batch or a trial recipe. Either way, the vessel needs a stopper and an airlock during fermentation, so check what comes in the box before you buy.
The gear: four picks, ranked
The four picks below are listed from the strongest overall match to the weakest, scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty from the figures the makers state. Three are vessels and one is a stopper, and the notes say so plainly. The table gives the short version; the notes after it give the detail.
| Vessel | Material | Size | In the box |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy Set | Soda-lime glass | 5 gallons, 11.0 x 11.0 x 19.0 inches | 2 carboys, 2 stoppers, 2 airlocks |
| North Mountain Supply Glass Carboy | Italian glass | 5 gallons | Carboy, 2 stoppers, 6-bubble airlock |
| FastRack 1 Gallon Glass Jug | Glass | 1 gallon, 7.0 x 7.0 x 11.0 inches | Jug, rubber bung, twin bubble airlock, polyseal cap |
| Ziliny Wood Cork Stopper, 2 Pack | Oak | Fits 3, 5 and 6 gallon carboys | 2 stoppers |
Suzile 5 Gallon Glass Carboy Set. The Suzile set is the only one here with two vessels: two 5 gallon glass carboys, each listed at 11.0 x 11.0 x 19.0 inches, with two drilled silicone stoppers and two airlocks. The glass is soda-lime glass, and the maker states a maximum temperature of 40 degrees Celsius, with a warning that high-temperature sterilization, hot water and short hot and cold changes can break the glass. During fermentation the maker says to keep the venting valve in use to release air and never to seal the glass. It suits a brewer who wants two fermenters and a complete kit in one order.
North Mountain Supply Glass Carboy. The North Mountain carboy is a 5 gallon fermenting jug in clear Italian glass, listed as a premium vessel for large-batch beer and wine. The kit includes drilled and undrilled rubber stoppers and a 6-bubble airlock, so fermenting can begin at once. The maker says the Italian glass avoids the seam-splitting issues seen in lower-quality alternatives, and the clear glass lets you watch the brew as it ferments. It suits a brewer who wants one large vessel with both stopper types on hand.
FastRack 1 Gallon Glass Jug. The FastRack jug is a clear 1 gallon glass jug, listed at 128 oz and 3.8 liter, measuring 7.0 x 7.0 x 11.0 inches. The purchase includes a #6.5 drilled rubber bung, a twin bubble airlock and a black polyseal cap. The maker lists the jug as reusable, a sustainable alternative to plastic containers, and the clear glass lets you watch the contents and know when a refill is due. It suits a brewer who works in small batches of beer, wine, cider, mead or kombucha.
Ziliny Wood Cork Stopper, 2 Pack. The Ziliny stoppers are the odd one out here: they are not vessels, but oak stoppers that fit 3, 5 and 6 gallon carboys. The set holds 2 stoppers, listed at 1.3 x 0.87 x 1.57 inches, molded and polished from oak, with small holes that the maker calls normal for natural oak. The maker lists the stoppers as airtight seals that keep home brews fresh, with pores that control air exchange for aging wine. The maker lists two sizes for these stoppers, so measure your carboy mouth before ordering. They suit a brewer who already owns a carboy and needs a replacement for plastic stoppers.
How to choose the best carboy vs cider jug
Match the vessel to the batch
Batch size decides the vessel. The 5 gallon carboys suit large batches of beer, wine, cider or mead, and the Suzile set gives you two of them for back-to-back batches. The 1 gallon FastRack jug suits a small batch or a trial recipe, and it stores easily on a shelf when empty. If you brew one batch at a time, one large carboy is enough; if you brew often, a second vessel keeps the next batch moving. Our best cider making kit guide lines up kits by batch size.
Check the fittings before you buy
A fermenter is only complete with a stopper and an airlock. The Suzile set and the North Mountain kit include both, and the FastRack jug includes a bung, a twin bubble airlock and a polyseal cap. The Ziliny stoppers are sold on their own for carboys that arrive without one, and they fit 3, 5 and 6 gallon carboys. Count the stoppers and airlocks in the box against the vessels you own, and buy the missing pieces with the vessel. See our how to use an airlock for fermentation guide for the setup.
Glass care and the airlock
Glass carboys need gentle handling. The Suzile maker states a maximum temperature of 40 degrees Celsius and warns that high-temperature sterilization, hot water and short hot and cold changes can break the glass. Keep the venting valve in use during fermentation so air can escape, and never seal the glass while it ferments. The North Mountain maker notes that its Italian glass avoids seam-splitting, but no glass vessel suits rough handling. See the difference between materials in our glass carboy vs plastic carboy comparison.
FAQ: preserving at home
What is a carboy?
A carboy is a large glass fermenting vessel, usually 5 gallons, with a narrow mouth that takes a stopper and an airlock. The carboys in this guide are 5 gallon glass vessels for beer, wine, cider and mead.
What is a cider jug?
A cider jug is a smaller glass vessel, often 1 gallon, used to ferment and store cider and other drinks. The jug in this guide is a 1 gallon glass jug with a bung, a twin bubble airlock and a polyseal cap.
Can I use a carboy for cider?
Yes. The Suzile carboy lists cider among the drinks it ferments, along with beer, wine, mead and kombucha, and the North Mountain carboy lists cider among its large-batch uses.
Do carboys come with airlocks?
The Suzile set and the North Mountain kit both include airlocks with their stoppers, and the FastRack jug includes a twin bubble airlock. The Ziliny stoppers are sold without airlocks.
How hot can a glass carboy get?
The Suzile maker states a maximum temperature of 40 degrees Celsius for its glass, and warns that high-temperature sterilization and hot water can break it. Keep the glass away from heat and sudden temperature changes.
More preserving guides
See every wine and cider making guide and all home brewing and wine guides.
More picks: carboy vs fermenter bucket, glass carboy vs plastic carboy, glass vs plastic cider jug and cider making kits.





