On this page
Small vs large food mill comes down to batch size: a small mill suits a pot of sauce at a time, while a large mill suits harvest-day batches that fill pots and jars. The listings here show the range: the Norpro states 2 quarts and the Zerodis states 917 ml on the small end, while the Louis Tellier N.3 states 5 quarts on the large end. Match the mill to the biggest batch you actually make, and check the disc sizes before you buy.
HarvestGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Small vs large food mill: the short answer
Buy small if you mill one pot of tomatoes or apples at a time. The Norpro multi-purpose food mill states a 2 quart capacity at 16 ounces, and the Zerodis states 917 ml, both stainless steel and both sized for everyday cooking. A small mill is easier to store, quicker to wash, and less tiring to crank for a single batch.
Buy large if you mill in harvest-season batches. The Louis Tellier N.3 states a 5 quart capacity and processes up to 3.3 lbs (1.5 kg) of food per minute while holding back skins and seeds. That is more than double the Norpro’s stated 2 quarts, so a big tomato day needs far fewer refills. For related size questions, see our small vs large food dehydrator guide.
What counts as small and what counts as large
Food mill sizes are stated in quarts or milliliters. The small mills here: the Norpro at 2 quarts (its included components list 2.2 qt) and the Zerodis at 917 ml. The large mills: the Louis Tellier N.3 at 5 quarts. The Chencheerio and Compralo listings do not state a capacity, so treat them as mid-size only if their other figures suit you.
Dimensions matter for storage as much as capacity. The Norpro measures 13.5 inches long by 7.25 inches wide, while the Compralo measures 14.37 by 16.14 by 3.62 inches and weighs 1.7 pounds. A large mill takes real counter and cabinet space, so measure before harvest season. Browse every food mill guide for the category.
Batch size decides the size
Count the batch, not the ambition. One pot of tomato sauce for tonight fits the small mills: the Norpro’s 2 quarts or the Zerodis’s 917 ml handle a pot or two with one fill. The Louis Tellier N.3’s 5 quarts and 3.3 lbs per minute throughput suit the cook who processes a bushel of tomatoes for canning jars in one session.
Refills are the real cost of a small mill. Milling 5 quarts of cooked tomatoes through a 2 quart mill means at least three fills, three cranking sessions and three cleanouts of the skins. A large mill does it in one fill. If you only mill baby food or a single pie’s worth of apples, the small mill is the easier tool to own.
Discs and texture
Disc hole sizes decide what comes out, and both sizes of mill offer them. The Louis Tellier N.3 includes 3 discs: 1.5 mm, 2.5 mm and 4 mm, from fine coulis and baby food to thicker purees and rustic soups. The Chencheerio includes fine (3 mm), medium (5 mm) and coarse (8 mm) discs for baby puree, smooth sauce and coarse mashed potatoes.
Small mills may ship with fewer discs. The Norpro listing describes the mill as a masher, ricer and strainer with no disc count stated, while the Compralo states three interchangeable discs (coarse, medium, fine). If you want both silky sauce and rustic mash from one tool, check that the listing states the disc sizes before choosing by size alone.
Materials and cleaning
Stainless steel dominates both sizes. The Norpro, Zerodis, Compralo and Chencheerio all state stainless steel, and the Chencheerio states food-grade stainless steel. The Louis Tellier N.3 is traditional tinned steel, and its listing says to hand wash and dry right away to protect the tin coating.
Cleaning ease matters more with large mills because large batches make large messes. The Compralo states its food-grade steel is dishwasher safe, and the Norpro comes apart for easy cleaning. The Louis Tellier is hand wash only per its tin coating warning. If you hate hand washing, that single fact can decide the size for you.
FAQ: preserving at home
Is a large food mill better for canning tomatoes?
For big tomato days, yes. The Louis Tellier N.3 states 5 quarts and up to 3.3 lbs per minute, so it keeps up with canning batches far better than the 2 quart Norpro.
What size food mill do I need for baby food?
Small is plenty. The Zerodis at 917 ml or the Norpro at 2 quarts handle baby-food batches, and the Chencheerio’s fine 3 mm disc suits smooth purees.
Do small food mills have interchangeable discs?
Some do. The Compralo states three interchangeable discs, while the Norpro listing states no disc count, so check the listing before assuming.
More preserving guides
See every food mill guide and all harvest and processing guides.
More picks: electric tomato juicer vs food mill, small vs large food dehydrator and cider press vs fruit press.





